Q&A with Jayro Bustamante and Gustavo Matheu

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of La Llorona.

Can you tell us about the evolution of this film?

Jayro Bustamante: Well, you know, at the beginning we were thinking about making a triptych, and that that triptych would be about three insults that are common in Guatemala and that people are accustomed to hearing all the time. And those insults, in my point of view, increase discrimination and separation between different circles of society. So the first of these insults is “indio,” and we know that in Guatemala that most of the population can trace their ancestry to indigenous peoples, the Mayan. It’s very… sad, to understand that for us, the product of our origin is something we are supposed to be ashamed of when we’re called “indio.” The second insult is “homosexual.” And it’s not only because we are a homophobic society, but it’s also intended to be an insult because they are essentially saying that if you are gay you are feminine, and therefore if you are feminine you are a lesser person. So at the end, the insult is towards all women as well. It’s very misogynistic. And the third insult is “communist.” And that insult is not about the fact that you’re part of a specific political ideology, it’s more coming from the 1950’s, when the United States had a lot of influence in Guatemala, and to be “communist” was to be the enemy. Even in the present day, it’s still a big insult to level at someone— it’s saying you’re an enemy of the state. Today, all the people who defend human rights, or social rights, or independent rights are called “communists.” So we wanted to talk about that third insult in La Llorona. The other two would have their own films. But in La Llorona we wanted to talk about that third insult. We were thinking about the fact that the world perceives a country that doesn’t respect human rights was finished by a genocide. So we started thinking about how to talk about that subject if my country doesn’t want to talk about it. And we made a kind study of which films Guatemalan’s were going to the theater to see. We found that they were consuming two main kinds: Superhero films, and horror films. So coming from that, we decided to use the legend of La Llorona as a way in. For us, La Llorona is a kind of cultural icon, and she comes from the horror universe. So it was very… I think very smart! To use that mythological character to talk about Guatemala’s recent history. 

We ended up editing the film, which is not normal for a director and a producer

Gustavo, as a producer, how did you figure into the creation of the story, once you’ve decided to very intentionally make it accessible to a commercial market?

Gustavo Matheu: It’s something I really loved being involved with, because when Jayro invited me to collaborate originally, it was not only to work on films (which is obviously what I love), but it was also to use cinema as a tool to address issues in out country and in Latin America in general. And this was Jayro’s idea from the beginning. He did it with Ixcanul and with Tremors, and now with La Llorona. It’s not only about making films as a way of entertainment. For me, being involved in those projects that are not only aimed at making money in a theater, but are also intended to make people talk about things that are actually important, inspires me and makes want to be more involved in every aspect of the filmmaking process. And La Llorona was a film where we both got very very involved. We ended up editing the film, which is not normal for a director and a producer! But we knew the story, and we wanted to get it to the end. So we were very hands-on with the film the entire time. It was a beautiful experience and an honor.

How aware is the current generation about the atrocities that occurred in Guatemala?

JB: We wanted to talk about that in the film— we wanted to represent three different, or even four different generations in the film. And the generation represented by the character of Carmen, which is the generation that really lost the empathy for the suffering of all the Mayan people, of the victims, coming from the war. And I was thinking about the fact that this is a generation of people who lost that empathy, and how it would be appropriate if a ghost came to haunt them, to show them how the other people suffered. And the second generation is the one represented by Natalia in the film. And she’s kind of my generation— we really grew up with fear, and we’re still living with fear. So we have a lot of questions. And we start opening doors, but we don’t have the courage to go through them afterward. And the third generation is represented by the character of Sara. I don’t know if her generation will be like Natalia’s; I hope it won’t be. Maybe I’m unfairly putting the responsibility on that generation. But I think they will open and go through those doors, and they will look for answers. And the fourth generation — that I really like — is represented by Valeriana, the other Mayan who works in that house. And that’s the generation that has suffered the worst, because they are people who are living in those kinds of houses, serving those kinds of people, even if they know what those people have done and what they think. And in a way they are forced to love them and say ‘thank you’ anyway. So all of that is what we wanted to show in the film.

Q&A with Pete Doctor, Kemp Powers, and Dana Murray

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Soul.

Can you talk about the design of the film and how it’s another evolution for Pixar both in the extremes of realism and surrealism that it achieves? It’s a New York film, but there’s also the astral plane.

Pete Docter: One of the big joys for me in working in this business is to embrace stuff that is perfect for animation. It’s a bit of a subjective term but it was the thing that drove me to think about the concept for Inside/Out… how do we personify emotions as abstract as that? In this film, we learned pretty quickly that souls generally are thought of by various religious traditions as ethereal and non-physical and vaporous and invisible. So this was a real challenge. I also think that, particularly in the U.S., we are conditioned to think of animation as something for kids. There’s no reason for that; you don’t go to a museum and say “oh, oil paintings, that’s for kids.” It’s capable of anything and we’re so lucky to work at a place that allows us to push the boundaries of that box. This film was definitely doing that for us!

Jazz is the perfect metaphor for the central themes of our film

Kemp, the story about how you came to co-direct this film is pretty remarkable.

Kemp Powers: Yeah, I was brought on as a writer about two years into the process. And I think that in the process of making Pixar films, there are often several writers that come on throughout—it wasn’t unusual. I think the fact that I got made a co-director was unique. A lot of that came from where the film was at that point. I was definitely looped into to lots of other elements of the film that writers aren’t typically involved with, everything from casting to character design and set design to our culture trust, both internal and external. It was probably eight months to a year into the process as the script was really getting tight that Pete and Dana actually asked me to become co-director and of course I asked “what does that mean?” and I found out that I had kind of been doing that the whole time! There were a lot of things that we learned in the process of making this film. This was a slightly unusual creative process even within the realm of Pixar films.

You mentioned this phrase “culture trust.” Can you expand on that?

Dana Murray: We have an internal culture trust which is a group of some of the black employees at Pixar that we bring along during the entire creative process of the film. We’d have screenings where we put the reels together, the storyboards, dialogue and music and all that and then we have typical notes session with our brain trust. But then we also have a notes session afterwards just with our culture trust, to see if there are things that don’t feel right or how we can make scenes feel more culturally authentic. They also review characters and sets as well and they really contributed quite a bit to this film. It was great because it was such a diverse group even within the culture trust. We wanted to make sure there was a lot of gender diversity and age diversity, a range of where people grew up. That was kind of the fun of it because everyone has a different opinion of things! Trying to figure out which direction to go after those note sessions could sometimes be tricky but was also really rewarding.

The music is so integral to the story. To me it was such an incredible sonic experience—it became apparent how tightly the Jon Batiste work was intertwined with Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross’s work in a way that’s not just score, but part of the story.

PD: Ren Klyce—who did our sound design—is amazing. It was through him we hooked up with Trent and Atticus. What we learned in working on their music with them is that sonically it’s not just played on speakers up front. It becomes part of the experience; you’re in this scene. The music becomes part of the sound design and the ambience of the world. So that was new, as well as the way they worked. We’re used to having our temp music up until the picture locks, and then you hand it off to the composer, and then they write to picture. In this instance, they were giving us cues as we were still re-writing and editing, so we would cut it in and do a lot of editing and mucking around and then return it to them to polish. They were much more involved in the process in a very organic way. And of course with Batiste, we needed to record him before the animation so we could match. That’s the way dialogue is done. You record the actors and then the animators listen and they’re looking for these ways to synchronize the sound with the picture that just completes this illusion that the sound is coming out of the character. By recording Batiste first, the animators could match every finger, every gesture and even push it further than real life. Music was a huge part of this movie. Maybe someone else wants to talk about the thematic elements of jazz.

KP: Jazz is honestly the perfect metaphor for the central themes of our film. Its’s improvisational, like life itself. You have to take whatever is thrown at you and turn it into something beautiful. Which was always a good argument to have whenever someone would ask “really, a kids movie about jazz?” and we always said no, we need it, it’s core to the central story we’re trying to tell. Fortunately, when we tested it out on kids, they really leaned in on the performative aspects of jazz. It’s alluring to children, seeing someone playing the saxophone and fingering or banging away on the piano keys. It actually really drew kids in.

Can you talk about developing the look of the film with your Cinematographer, crafting the lighting and camerawork, and also the contributions of the great Bradford Young?

PD: The way we work is that we have two DPs, traditionally. We had Matt Aspury, our DP of layout, and Ian Megibbon, who was lighting. Those guys came to us and said the ultimate New York films are those iconic ones from the 70s. So let’s try to approximate the same film stock, the same lens choice, so we had anamorphic lenses which you can kind of tell from the way it sort of blurs in the background. It was important and really fit into the overall design because we wanted the ethereal world to be clean and soft and fuzzy and this world is gritty and hard-edged. So there’s a really great opposition and contrast.

KP: Bradford is known, among many other things, for how well he lights black skin and black characters. We had a great variety of black complexions in the film so it behooved us to have him on board as a consultant, and Ian is a huge fan of Bradford. Bradford actually came in a few different times and didn’t just discuss lighting black skin but some other techniques of lighting that he uses that we hadn’t really used before. Like Bradford does this wonderful thing with single source lighting, where sometimes there will be light coming from a single source and it will cast a character in a shadow in a way that previously we wouldn’t have done in a Pixar-animated film. But he gave these great discussions about lighting and the subversive things that lighting can say about wealth versus poverty. He put this all into an incredible historical context. Our lighting team really took it to heart. It’s so funny because we hear people say that the film looks photorealistic, but it’s not. I think some of those lighting techniques are responsible for what appears to some people to be a photorealistic look.

What makes for a great voice actor? Is it just about the voice or is there something else?

DM: Our process is that first we design a character and spend a lot of time trying to figure out what they look like. Then as we get closer to needing to cast with the casting department, we ask them to provide a ton of voices but we don’t want to know who the actors are, so we can listen to these while we look at the character design. Sometimes you can tell, obviously, if it’s someone super recognizable. But for the most part you don’t know. You want the voice to fit with the design you have. I think what makes the best voice actors are the ones that can go in and not just deliver what’s in the script, but have fun and deliver lines that aren’t on-script, because those tend to be the funniest.  

Q&A with Chloé Zhao and Mollye Asher

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Nomadland.

Your films feel so naturalistic— as though you just took your crew to a location and filmed what was going on there. But the reality is quite different, isn’t it?

Chloé Zhao: Well, the trick is to make the audience feel like we just showed up. That we have not planned or manipulated the situation… but of course we did! And, you know, it’s not that different from a more traditional film: we start with a script, and the script gives us the parameters, so it’s a road movie… So the locations come first. And then we go from there.

Mollye Asher: After Chloé finalizes the script, we’ll know exactly what she needs. By that I mean, there will be specific places that Chloé knows for sure that she wants. For example, Wall Drug in South Dakota is a very famous place, and so we’ll go through that process of getting those locations. But then there are other things that Chloé and Josh, through their travels, are going to find as they’re location scouting. For instance, for the mechanic, Chloé and Josh drove around to a lot of different places until they found one that was interesting looking. And when they did that, they found this amazing character, Ken, who is in the film. So a lot of times the casting of locations is also casting the actors.  

I don’t believe in “locking” the script until the morning of the last day of the shoot

It’s fascinating that Fern was not in the book, and is so central to the film. How did you create her?

CZ: We divided the whole story by three: There’s a third from the book, a third from the lives of our previous films and our travels, and another third from Fran, really. Including locations as well— for instance, the redwoods, and the Pacific coast… those places were very dear to Fran. We knew from the start that Jessica Bruder [the author of the book] had captured such a unique time in America. Everything from Empire Nevada to work camping at Amazon to Bee Harvest Nebraska. It’s a very rich, rich world that she built. We needed to create a character that had a strong enough of an emotional arc to be able to take us through that kind of territory. And for us, to be able to very greedily include as much as we could from her book. And so we collaborated with Fran to create a character that’s sort of a version of Fran — the same way that the non-professional actors were going to play versions of themselves. So that’s sort of how Fern was created.

How did you crew this film? It must be a delicate task, given that you are placing non-actors alongside a master like Frances McDormand.

MA: We brought them with us on the road. And, you know, casting crew is something we’ve done on all of Chloé’s movies. It’s very important, because we’re going into communities that are not our own. We try to find crew that can, in a way, become invisible. And that they will be OK with that idea, too. We took a long time looking for what I kind of call “unicorns,” because they are able to do many different jobs and that’s key to these small crews. I think we had twenty three people in total. And then of course, you know, finding personalities that all work together. Because you’re all living together for so long.

Can you talk about the scene between Fern and the young boy? It was absolutely amazing.

CZ: Basically, the character was in the script, but… the thing about the script is, it’s sometimes more of a placeholder. And I don’t believe in “locking” the script until the morning of the last day of the shoot. That’s when the script locks for me. Like, before I met Derek [Endres], the character was supposed to be a young girl named Echo who was pregnant and on the road. And then we went out to look for Echo. And Hannah Peterson, who helped us with casting, filmed a bunch of young people she met who were living in tents in the dessert. And from those videos, there was Derek. And as soon as he started speaking, we were like, “there’s our character!” What era is this guy from?! It was like he had just walked out of a Walt Whitman poem. So we found him… and then we had to re-find him, right Mollye? He took a bus somewhere and you had to track him down. But you did, and then we got to know him… and just incorporated him into the film. We rewrote the scene for him, very similarly to how we wrote the scenes for the other main characters of the RTR, and rewrote the scenes based on some of the stuff they said, so we didn’t have to hire actors to play them— we had them play themselves. So the process isn’t really that different, they just have to memorize a few lines (which they’ve basically already said), and that’s it.

Fern is so natural in her body. It’s both beautiful and surprising, for the audience.

CZ: Well, I think for much of that I have to give credit to Fran. From early on, we wanted to celebrate aging. To celebrate the full arc of life. Because you know, sunsets are beautiful — and yes, it’s towards the end, but it depends on how you look at it. And I think unfortunately in our culture, in this country where the cosmetic industry is so enormous, and also in the film business itself, we’re quite focused on appearing a certain way. Even in cinematography, Josh has talked about this— we don’t want to put too much between the lens and the audience. We want you to see Fran as she sees her own face and her own body, without all the filters and lighting to help. We want to truly believe in our audience and have faith in our audience, and trust that they will find that being human is beautiful. And I think we feel pretty good about that so far with the responses we’ve gotten to the film.

Q&A with Garrett Bradley

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Time.

This is such a moving film. What was your emotional reaction as a filmmaker while telling this story? 

Garrett Bradley: Part of the impetus for me in making a project is that I’m already emotionally affected by something. I’m not going out and looking for stories. I think I’ve been incredibly lucky to be working in a space where the projects develop out of real relationships and things I’m already in proximity to. That isn’t to say I didn’t learn things or that my emotional capacity was still limited. I think a part of what has become really clear as the film has come out and been seen by people is that their questions really affirm and illuminate what was really meaningful and important to me in the making of the film. It’s very much tied to visibility and this question of erasure and of thinking about the abstract nature of 2.3 million people that are incarcerated. It was always really important to think about the effects of the facts. It’s about the rippling effect. It’s about what we really understand on a human and emotional level about 2.3 million people being incarcerated. When we think about this current moment and police brutality and the uprisings and the incredible role of the white allyship that is unprecedented that we’ve seen this year, so much of that is tied to optics, tied to visibility, tied to technology. And yet, when we think about the prison industrial complex, I think it really illuminates the void that exists there in being able to see what 2.3 million incarcerated people looks like. The only way to prove that and to show the effects of that is with the family, with those that are on the outside. In the process of making the film, those ideas and realities were only reaffirmed with me in a very real and visceral way.  

it was very clear that the film was going to be something wildly different than what I had envisioned

Can you talk about putting together the structure of the film? It’s unconventional and very effective.

I had originally thought I was making another short film. And the purpose of that was for me to focus on the minutiae and really illustrate how the system unequivocally embeds itself in daily life so you can’t separate yourself from the system. I spent a lot of time with Fox at work and in these very specific moments that I thought would help show and indicate that. When I thought I was done shooting—as you know, when you’re making a documentary, you have to shop shooting at some point for budget or deadline reasons—I remember saying to Fox, I’m going to come back and show you a cut of the film. And right as I was leaving, she handed me a hundred hours’ worth of her own personal home archive that she herself had not looked at since she shot it in the 90s. She knew a little bit about what was on the tapes but hadn’t really combed through it or curated it in any way. At that moment, it was very clear that the film was going to be something wildly different than what I had envisioned, and hopefully for the better.

Why did you choose to present the film in black and white? Were Fox’s videos shot that way?

The archive was actually all in color. I had really thought about this being a sister film to my short film, Alone. Alone was in black and white. This was this sort of superficial “I’m going to extrapolate the aesthetics and the pace and the tone from Alone” because I wanted the two films to feel very similar. It wasn’t until we began working through the archive that we considered going into color. But ultimately we were dealing with a lot of different textures and materiality and scales of colors, and I think for myself and Gabe Rhodes—who cut the film—it was really important to find a way to structure the film so that the mythology of love allowed there to be a perpetual sense of moving forward, but also gave us the freedom to come backwards. So we could oscillate between time as much as possible. The materiality of it, the visual element of it, was really going to be the thing that either helped us do that or not do that. To point to it versus allowing it to seem more fluid and more seamless and more linear, even though we were jumping around in the chronology. At the end of the day, even though we kind of came full circle with the original intention of black and white, it was ultimately in response to a lot of the creative questions and challenges we found ourselves asking in the process of making the film.

At the end of the film, Rob gives us an acronym for love: love is Life’s Only Valid Expression. It’s a beautiful quote from an amazing man. Can you tell us about that?

We talked about a number of things in the process of making this film. For me, it again goes back to the question, what is the intention of the folks I’m working with?  If the intention is to bring hope to the 2.3 million that are incarcerated, if not double or triple that number when we take into account those that are affected, how do I as a filmmaker translate that into my own practice, into the film, into the visual medium. I think what that turned into was thinking about resistance. How can the film also show different forms of resistance that we may take for granted, that we may not have as many optics for or visual examples of? When we think about resistance or protest, we might think about actually going out into the street and participating in something like a public protest. But how can we think about love, how can we think about a family staying together over the course of 21 years, how can we think about one’s ability to maintain their sense of individuality amidst the system… these are all forms of resistance. So I think that quote at the end of the film was incredibly important because we needed to hear from Rob. Even though for me the film ended once Fox and the family were successful in bringing him back home. It was also so crucial that he have a voice and that we see him and that he express himself in a way that felt true to himself. But I also felt it really reinforced this idea of what hope was, which is connected to these ideas of alternative forms of resistance. And love and unity and individuality are equally as powerful forms of resistance that all of us are engaging in every day. I wanted to celebrate and share that idea.

Q&A with Paul Greengrass and Helena Zengel

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of News of the World

Can you tell us about the origins of this film?     

Paul Greengrass: I think the origins of it lie in the last film I made, actually, 22 July, which was a pretty tough film about violent right-wing extremism in Europe. And I think it applied pretty much to most places, and it was rooted in the difficulties of our world today. But I did feel at the end of it that I wanted to explore more of the healing road, you know? That one was the story of a family and a young man that had been caught up in an attack, so necessarily there was a limit to how much you could answer the question, “how do we get out of this mess?” It was a true story, after all. And I find with films, if you ask yourself the right question, generally they come along. So then I was sent the novel, and I read the novel, and I thought, well this is it: this strange, beautiful story, set in the aftermath of the civil war about this lonely news reader who wanders from town to town with the healing power of storytelling… and he meets this mysterious young girl and they go on an odyssey through Texas to take her to her surviving family… They’re trying to find the road out of their divided world, as I think most of us today would like to find for our world. So that’s really where it started; I read the novel, and I thought, “that’s it.”  

You’ve got to be in a place where you are taken out of yourself and challenged

The depiction of the Kiowa tribe was fascinating. It came across as authentic, rich, and detailed. How did you work with the tribe?  

PG: That was the first real piece of work that we did when we started on the film, was to reach out to the Kiowa tribe and to talk to them, and ask their opinion of the novel (which they liked). We asked them to help us make the film, and we asked them what was important to them. That was crucial to us. What was most important to them, as they expressed many times, was the language: the film should reflect the beauty of the Kiowa language, and the fact that it’s alive, and that it’s spoken. And, secondly, that people from the Kiowa tribe should portray the Kiowa. That was very very important to them. And we followed their advice and we had some wonderful, wonderful times. They came to visit, and they stayed on the set, and of course Helena worked with them — particularly with Dorothy, who is an elder of the tribe, and a language expert — and she really took Helena under her wing, didn’t she?

Helena Zengel: She really did. She’s a great person. She’s over 90 years old! She really taught me a lot. And it was interesting to hear her version of the whole… mess, I’d say, when the white people took their land, and then what her people went through. Because, I mean, she was there. So it was interesting to hear that. And then also to really learn — not only parts of the language — but also to learn the culture, to learn their way of thinking, the importance of the circle… and also their way of living. Because they think and move differently than we do. Because we think in a straight line, and we’re very orderly, very oriented around money… and they’re, like, so free with things, compared to us. So it was very cool to hear her version of history, and to be able to talk to her because she knows a lot.

What was the most surprising thing for you, Helena, coming to the States to work on this film?

HZ: Well, first of all, that I’d really find a snake! I didn’t think— I mean, I knew there were going to be snakes, but to actually find one myself… I didn’t think that would happen. And then also it is so great in New Mexico. I’d never been to New Mexico, and it was so great to have America mixed with Mexico, kind of, because even though we were in America, everything was very… spicy! But there was also all of the typical American stuff, like fast food. I always only saw cowboys in movies, so I thought, “well, they won’t really be like that,” and then after the first day with the cowboys, I was just like, “mom… they are real! They’re not just in movies!” It’s true, they’re real. They’re like, “howdy ma’am!” Which made me so excited. That was very funny, to see that.

PG: There was one time, I don’t know if you remember this Helena, but one time you were sitting on the wagon with Tom — who by the way was just fantastic with you, looked after you so beautifully and was so generous — but one time you were sitting on the wagon while we were setting a shot up, and your microphone was live and you were chatting away with Tom, and I heard you say in a whisper, “Tom… does everybody curse all the time on an American film sets?!” And that was with us all being careful around her, too!

Paul, you spoke earlier about wanting to work in a different way than in your previous films when you started this project. As an experienced director, who are you able to depend on for advice and feedback when you’re moving into newer territory?

PG: Well, I think the answer is, I think filmmaking is a little bit like making music, you know? And when you work with new musicians, your music changes by its nature, because you’re working with different musicians who do different things that aren’t so predictable. So the honest answer is that it’s less about who you rely on, and more about who you choose to collaborate with, who come to you in a new way, you know? And that’s really, I think, the key to longevity in this business. You have to try to stretch yourself, you have to say, “well, I’m going to do a different sort of film where I’m out of my comfort zone,” so that’s the first thing you have to do. And then, maybe you have to make those choices to work with new people. Which takes you, again, out of your comfort zone. Because inevitably, you get that wonderful camaraderie you find with people that you’ve made with movies with over a long period of time. But with that, maybe you get to be a bit safe in your choices, because you rely on them so much. And, you know, the first movie I ever made in Hollywood The Bourne Supremacy, I remember deciding before I went that I was going to come on my own. I wasn’t going to bring anybody I’d made Bloody Sunday with, or those earlier films, because I knew it was going to be good for me, personally, to be out of my comfort zone with people who would… who would judge you. That’s the truth of it. You’ve got to be in a place where you are taken out of yourself and challenged. And that’s what Dariusz [Wolski] did for me, and other people too. And it’s wonderful– it makes you feel alive.