Q&A with Robert Machoian and Clayne Crawford

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of The Killing of Two Lovers.

Can you discuss your inspiration for writing this story?

Robert Machoian: It was really motivated, to some degree, my own life in the sense that I’ve been married for quite a while, and I have children, and coming to this period in life where many friends of ours were starting to separate. And separating while having children. And then some of my male friends in these situations acting very kind of out-of-character as they were beginning to realize that they were losing the every day experiences with their kids. That discussions about parenting they were having suddenly had only to do with weekends, and with packing the lives of their children into weekends. And many of these individuals were and are great fathers. So all of a sudden I was living in this world, and I wanted to explore it, to have a dialog about it. I wrote a short film called The Drift, and after talking with Clayne about it, we knew we should expand it, stretch it into a feature story instead of having it be just a short.

it’s a complexity of character that you rarely see in a script

Clayne, what were your impressions on first read-through? What made you want to play David?

Clayne Crawford: I guess as it relates to being in every scene of the film, I can’t say I was intimidated by that, or concerned about that. It was more a sense of excitement, really, knowing Robert’s style of filmmaking, and that I was going to have moments to allow this character just to be present. It’s just the style in which Robert makes films that really energized me and made me enthusiastic to get to know the character of David, and to understand where he was coming from, and to understand how broken he was… it’s a complexity of character that you rarely see in a script. And then in the next scene, he’s giggling with his children and telling jokes. Just how complex a character David was was really fascinating. That gave me a lot of hope as it related to the success of the story and the film, and especially that opening scene which, albeit jarring, forces the audience to have an immediate opinion of the character, and now they’ve got to sit with that for the next hour and twenty minutes, and how are they going to feel afterward? From a creative standpoint, that was all very interesting to me.

Did you know the kids before the shoot started, Clayne?

CC: One hundred percent. I’ve known most of Robert’s children since they were babies. We were in this small little town– Robert had rented out an artist’s loft (from a friend of his who lived down in Utah), and this loft was part of the century gymnasium that had been abandoned that the artist friend had turned into this beautiful space. And we were all just… there! If we weren’t in our own spaces sleeping, then we were there. So Jonah, for instance (the youngest), he climbed up into [Sepideh Moafi’s] lap right after dinner the day that she came to town, and fell asleep. So, they instinctively knew what was necessary to build a connection. Which was really special, and it’s just something… you know, where there are hotels, and you’re in a big city, and there’s a lot of money, and trailers… you don’t get the opportunities that we had on this film, because, again, we were all eating together and hanging out together all day every day. 

The story is many things at once: a family drama, a romance, a thriller, and at times, a horror story. How did you approach the sound design for such a complicated dramatic tone, and as an actor, did that figure into your preparation at all?

RM: Immediately, when we knew we were going to be doing this film, I reached out to Peter [Albrechtsen] to really begin to discuss this exact topic. What I said to him was that we were going to be shooting the film in a way that required the sound design to play a significant role in helping the audience understand David’s mental state, and to get at the chaos of him. Because I felt that if we could, as an audience, understand how challenging life is for him at the moment, and not do it in a dialog scene with his best friend or something like that… and to build it, we would understand the risks that David was taking. There might be a decision that David makes, or that we hope he will not make, and through sound come to understand the chaos in and of itself – not that you would understand it per se – but that you would help the audience get at the essence of what was going on in his head during those challenging moments. So early on Peter and I really discussed it in depth. I discussed it with Clayne as well, and he can speak to that, but I don’t know that even he or I really understood where we’d end up going with the sound until Peter contributed.

CC: I agree, I think that was what was exciting about this approach that we took, the indie approach that we took where it was pretty much just Robert and I kind of in charge of how the film was going to be put together. And to give someone like Peter – who we both felt was extremely talented – a lot of freedom. Sometimes you spend a lot of time and energy just trying to get someone who you’re working with to get to the level that you’re wanting the film to be, and with Peter he showed up on day one and far exceeded what we were expecting. So I agree with Robert– I didn’t expect, and I don’t even know… I don’t think even Peter expected the sound design to play throughout the film as much as it did. And I just feel like it elevated the film in such a way to where we felt David’s state of mind – as Robert mentioned – without him having to articulate it. We felt what he was going through.

Q&A with Quoc Bao Tran and Yuji Okumoto

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of The Paper Tigers.

This film is a heartfelt look at the Kung Fu genre as well as a story about growing up and fatherhood in various forms. What was the catalyst for the story?

Bao Tran: I survived a death match and wanted to tell a story about it… no, I wish it were that dramatic but it’s not! A lot of the camcorder scenes you see in the film are a homage to the types of films I made growing up in the backyard with my dad’s camcorder. As an Asian-American it’s not the most encouraging profession to get into, so there was a lot of sneaking out to do so and a lot of that vibe went into this story. Making movies as a hobby is different than going into it as a profession. As I was getting older and getting into the business side of it and dealing with some of the seedier stuff, I was feeling a little jaded and worn out. So I wanted to rekindle the passion I once had for filmmaking. The other love I had growing up was Martial Arts. I bounced off that as an idea and that’s how I rolled it into The Paper Tigers—I wanted to rediscover the things I once had passion for and see if they still held meaning. I was watching The Big Chill, and it’s a bit like a “Kung Fu Big Chill” while it’s also its own thing of loving the genre and turning it askew.

I wanted to rediscover the things I once had passion for and see if they still held meaning

Yuji, how did you become involved in the project?

Yuji Okumoto: Like Bao, I too survived a death match—it’s called independent filmmaking. Bao and I have known each other since 2009 and worked together on several projects up here in Seattle Washington. Being a big fan of Kung Fu and growing up with the genre and participating in Karate, I read the script and I loved the idea of these washed-up dudes trying to find their glory. I can relate to that… I’m 62 and if I were to try and throw a kick right now, I might pull a hamstring. But the main reason I jumped on board was because I wanted to be part of a project that had a minority aspect to it. If I could be part of a film that features good lead roles for minorities, I was down.

It’s safe to save both of you are former Martial Arts practitioners in some shape or form.

BT: Yeah, and it’s definitely a love letter to Bruce Lee’s influence here in Seattle. We kind of have an unsung scene here that can get overlooked for the bigger cities. But when Bruce first arrived here after coming over from Hong Kong, he opened up a Martial Arts school here, he got married here, he went to the University of Washington. A lot of his students that he taught back in the day—who were very multi-cultural and multi-racial, since he was one of the first to teach non-Chinese Kung Fu—are still around. They’re still teaching and passing on the things they learned from Bruce. In many ways, we are in that grand lineage of Bruce Lee. That’s the part of the backdrop as well.

Speaking of diversity, how did you come up the cast?

BT: With casting, we kind of knew what the breakdown was going to be. I obviously wanted it to reflect my childhood and my friends within my Kung Fu experience and the dynamic that we had among each other. When we began to fundraise, we got a lot of notes to make it more “bankable” and to add more opportunities to cast white actors. We had a bunch of offers on the table and we didn’t bite because it would have required us to change that breakdown. So we said thanks but no thanks, and went to Kickstarter and tried to find different investors completely outside of LA and the traditional film financing structure.

How long did the whole process take?

BT: Ten years of clawing and scratching; nothing was linear. If we really break it down, nothing was traditional about the way we made this film. We had a portion of the film at about year five. We had some of the money in place and decided to shoot the first ten pages of the film, when the characters are younger in the 80s and 90s portion. So you have the pre-teen and the young adult versions and we knew we could shoot them out and be done with it. It was categorically a short film according to SAG because they didn’t know what to do with us! Once we had part of the movie in hand, we used that as a pitch reel and for on our Kickstarter and went to a few film labs and found a sales agent from that and then were able to shoot the film two years later. In a lot of ways, the casts were stand-alones because we didn’t know who our main cast was going to be when we shot the earlier footage.  We wanted to shoot to put it in the can; shooting to make a reel felt like a waste of time.

Fatherhood and legacies and disciples are such strong themes in this film. Can you speak to that a bit?

BT: For me, I saw Danny as a person escaping and running away from responsibility. And then at the end, he can’t squirm away anymore. It’s time for him to confront where he is. We talked about code-switching a lot. When he’s with his kid or ex-wife, Danny can be that charmer, but when he’s with his brothers, that won’t get by them. And he’s also their senior, so when he says something with authority, it goes. But that comes with accountability; if he flakes out in front of them, there’s hell to pay. In that third act, we wanted to land in that moment where his shirking his Kung Fu responsibility is also his shirking his “dad” responsibility and to have that all come to a head.

YO: The character of Danny has a great arc. He started off as this studly guy and then he has a fall from grace and becomes a regular dude that has lost his skills and his mojo. His dynamic shifted as the film progressed—he’s still trying to be that father figure but I just think he wasn’t able to take the time to communicate with his son. That’s the crux of his whole problem, the communication factor… asking his son to lie about this and cover for that. It’s a wonderful character because he’s flawed and as human beings, we’re all flawed in different ways. I think a lot of people will be able to relate to Danny’s character and when he triumphs at the end, I think it’s a payoff for both his character and the audience.  

Yuji, what were some of the challenges you faced as a producer on the film?

YO: There were a ton of them, especially when you’re doing indie! The biggest challenge for the producers as a collective was that we’re all creators and come from the creative side of the business. But being a producer, we have to be able to fundraise. Asking for a few dollars here and a few there is really hard but it all adds up. At the end of the day, what we realized by going through this whole journey was that it does take a village to make this all come together. It’s a collective of a wonderful support group and everyone we reached out to really stepped up. It was a roller coaster of emotions and wins and losses but we were so lucky to have this support system up here in Seattle Washington.

Q&A with Dominic Cooke

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of The Courier.

What was your approach to developing the look of the film? The 1960’s is an era we all know so well, but this felt different somehow.

Dominic Cook: In the early ’60’s in the UK, you might as well have been in the Edwardian era. Things simply had not changed! They changed politically in some ways after the second World War of course: they built the welfare state and the National Health Service; there were these big structural changes. But on the surface, life hadn’t changed at all. And the culture was still obsessed with sort of upper-middle-class, formal, domestic concerns. And that model, the sort of “empire” model of behavior, was absolutely the norm. And then within two or three years, The Beatles started, there was a huge amount of social legislation and upheaval, political protest… the world really started to shift. But in the early ’60’s, you could really have been at any time in the 20th century. So that was useful, because it told you where people’s values were, how they behaved, etc. I mean, we were just really hoping, with the aesthetic of the film, to avoid the obvious clichés. And the obvious cliché would be, “isn’t the West lovely, isn’t the Soviet Union horrible.” And we absolutely weren’t interested in doing that. I mean, I’m extremely critical of the Soviet System, but even as a huge critic of the Soviet system, there were many great things about it and what it delivered for the people. Equally, the Britain of that time was incredibly class orientated, it was very excluding… So, you know, we wanted to show, really, in the way we made the film, that what the film is really about two individuals who are completely outside of their own systems. Both systems were quite rigid, both systems both didn’t like people behaving in unorthodox ways. So therefore we made certain aesthetic choices… we used the same colors, the same sort of ideas in how we were shooting both the Soviet Union and the UK. The architecture speaks for itself, because obviously the buildings and the spaces look different. But that was the way we went. That conditioned our decisions. And the other thing was that I wanted it to feel more textured and rough than films depicting the time often do. It’s very hard not to make European movies look sort of appetizing and sentimental! Like, “wouldn’t it be good if we all lived in that time,” and I didn’t want that, I wanted it feel a bit edgier than that. So we restricted the pallet very harshly, we had very strict rules: there was to be absolutely no nature in the film (in fact we broke that rule twice: there’s a golf outing and there’s a camping holiday), but other than that, there are absolutely no trees at all. And I kept saying, “we’re not going to any locations with trees!” Because it’s really about these two guys caught in these systems. And we wanted to reflect that in the visuals. We made some rules, and we tried to stick by those rules.

The people were being trained not to feel, and if they did feel, not to show feeling

You have a background is in theater, but the film editing here is really incredible. It feels like there is no cutting at all. Can you discuss how you approached the edit?

DC: We actually had two totally brilliant editors working on this film. It was a long process— it took an entire year. It took a year because it was really about how much do you show, and how much do you not show. If you give the audience too much, you make them passive. And audiences are quick these days, and they’re smart. And so you often don’t need to give them that much, but if you don’t give enough they sort of disconnect. So it was a strange process of withholding information lots of the time, but also sort of really clarifying what the genre was. So for example, there is something inherently funny about the opening situation, where you have this rookie guy who’s just going to lunch with someone and then he’s asked to be involved in an international espionage mission! Which is actually what happened. And it’s quite funny. And I was very keen on the fact that is should be funny, because I think that humor and comedy allow an audience to connect with characters, it makes them listen. It reveals the humanity of the situation. But we had to get it right, because it was like, “this is almost too funny now,” and then the audience can’t come back to the seriousness of the film. What’s at stake when he gets off the plane in Moscow— he’s suddenly in a very dangerous situation. So those issues of balance were very important, and it was a really interesting process honing that. And then testing it with audiences… which is sort of a bizarre thing in and of itself. The danger of testing with an audience is that you ask them specific questions and they’ll give you specific answers. So yo have to receive that information very carefully. But there was a lot of useful information we got from that process, and I had two brilliant editors who worked so well on the fine-tuning of it.  

The scene between the protagonist and his wife, when she visits him in prison, is so quiet in spite of the tremendous underlying tension and emotion. Can you talk about your approach to there?

DC: I think Jessie Buckley is absolutely magnificent. If you’ve met her, you just can’t believe that she does what she does in this film, because she is the opposite of the character she plays. She’s so open, she’s so present… And available. And is quite young! And she totally understood both the extraordinary depth of feeling and the uptight upper-middle-class mentality that had to be shown simultaneously in that scene, and in general throughout her ordeal. Because she was quite a bit posher than her husband (who was from a working-class family). People in those days in Britain, they would change their actions, a lot, depending on their backgrounds and who they were speaking with. You were conditioned and bred and brought up not to show feeling. This comes from the empire. There is a really interesting interview with Rupert Everett in which he discussed his experience in the public school system. And he said that the public school system, the boarding school system, is designed to “cauterize emotion.” And that’s because the people that went there had to go off and run the empire. That’s why they were set up, those schools. And I thought that was quite revelatory. Because of course that passes down right through the whole of society. And it still exists now. The people were being trained not to feel, and if they did feel, not to show feeling. And that applied to women as well as men. So that’s a very long answer to your question, because the fact is that they were desperate in that scene: she thinks he’s going to die, and he wants to take away her pain, if you like. But they are trained to be unemotional. So those were the dynamics that were at play in that scene. And when we tested the film, interestingly, in the United States the demographics were really clear: women in the States didn’t get it, the first cut. They were like, “why the hell is she so cold?!” Women in Britain, on the other hand, didn’t say that! They sort of understood, you know, that this restraint she was showing was just social conditioning. So we actually went back and sort of “warmed it up” a bit in subsequent edits; we used takes where she showed slightly more vulnerability. It’s interesting, because it wasn’t the guys who split that way, in terms of US versus UK. So that’s an example of how the test-audience process turned out to be quite useful for us.

Q&A with Nikole Beckwith

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Together Together.

Films like this are so clearly made with love and rely on character. What inspired you to tell this story in the form of a feature film?

Nikole Beckwith: In terms of what inspired the story, it was just curiosity. I was very curious about what would happen to two strangers if they were thrown into such an emotionally-charged and intimate circumstance, as well as something that was integral in moving them each forward into their own separate independent futures. I was a playwright before I worked in film and I have one play that had a child that was the product of an egg donation show up in the first act, and then another play that also had a surrogate through line. But my plays are absurdist and farcical, and I wanted to explore these issues in a very grounded real-world way. The absurdist stuff was in my head and I wanted to see what would happen if I moved these ideas down into my heart.

The absurdist stuff was in my head and I wanted to see what would happen if I moved these ideas down into my heart

Your first film was remarkably different in tone. How did you make such a dramatic shift for Together Together?

NB: It is a shift, for sure. I was approached after Stockholm, Pennsylvania was at Sundance by the San Francisco Film Society. They asked me to apply for this female genre fellowship they offer, and I think everyone was assuming that I’d apply for horror or thriller, but I applied for comedy! This film’s tone is a balancing act so I’m not sure I would describe it as pure comedy, but that’s what came out of it. So I submitted an application and a pitch for this story, which I had been kicking around for a while. And I got the fellowship and went to San Francisco and started thinking about it in a real way and put digital pen to digital paper. I think because this story is nine months—I wanted to tell it from the moment they met until the baby was born—that inherent closed loop made it obvious to me that this would be a feature.  

There’s a great quote in the press notes: “it’s a movie that is funny without jokes, sweet without sap, romantic without sex, and timeless even as it springs from so many contemporary ideals.” That really captured what I felt watching the film; I never felt manipulated into feeling certain things. Do you tune that during the writing process or does it happen on set?

NB: I think it just comes out. I write a lot of internal prose in my screenplays; I’m putting a thread of what’s happening internally with those characters, but it’s a light touch. I think that helps set the tone for the actors. It’s a lot of what I would say on set. I’m a very actor-centric writer, so I think when I’m writing a script, I’m writing it as a poem or a letter to the people that are going to pick up the mantle. It’s about communicating as much as I can about the tone and about the tenor in the prose of the script. But of course it gets fine-tuned on set, and then again in a major way in the editing room. We could have made the movie any number of tones once I was in the editing room, but I wanted to stay really true to the intention of the script.

Do you shoot with that editing and fine tuning in mind? Are you asking for different energies from your actors in order to keep open the possibilities?

NB: There is an exploratory element—what if it’s like this, or imagine that—but I think largely that’s in service of finding the space. And also to have fun and loosen up. It depends scene to scene or moment to moment; if I feel like the best thing to do is come in hot, and then the deeper we go into the take, release, or if I think it’s best to come in with subtlety and let each next take get bigger. But I do think that’s mostly in service of the actors’ experience and finding your way through the character and the internal rhythm of it all.

Can you talk about assembling this incredible cast?

NB: I’ll immediately give a shout out to Richard Hicks, my amazing casting director. I sent him the script well before we were officially working on it, and we’d check in periodically. He’d ask me “what about this vibe?” and he’s just an incredible casting director to collaborate with. He was also a performer so he’s very actor-centric, he’s incredible when he’s reading with people, and I think that’s part of the reason so much of the cast is so magical. I was selfishly creating a list of who do I want to go to work with in the morning, who do I admire most, who do I have a crush on their talent. One of my first questions about casting, is “are they nice?” which I know is not necessarily the way to prioritize casting, but I do really like a warm set, a non-yelling set, a we’re-all-it-in-together set. You’re not making bank in movies of this size. In fact, not only are making less money, but you’re working harder and the days are longer and the pages you’re shooting per day are more! So it is important that the people that are coming on board are there for the right reasons—they’ve connected to the script, they’re excited about who is on screen with them, and we’re all sharing in that vibe. So Tig [Notaro] knows Ed [Helms], and Ed is friends with Patti [Harrison], and those dynamics make it fun. I’m such a huge fan of Sufe Bradshaw; I didn’t even realize that would be possible. It was a very cool process. I remember when we sent it to Ed, I was like, cool, who are we going to send it to next? Because I thought there was no way Ed would sign on. And then when Ed wanted to meet, it was like winning the lottery, and it was the same way with Patti. And then we had Anna Konkle coming in as the birth coach. PEN15 is I think one of the greatest shows I’ve ever seen and her physicality in that part is mind-blowing and so accurate. I felt so flattered when she stepped out of the PEN15 writers’ room for a day to play Shayleen and she did not disappoint. She’s very in her process and I loved watching her work. Every single day was like that! Fred Malemed, what an icon. Tig is so funny and present and her humanity and worldview is so rooted to everything she does. Even just having her positive and honest energy on set was such a big deal. Everyone’s contributions on set were to their roles, but also helping to create an environment where everyone is doing their best work and taking care of each other.

Q&A with Oliver Hermanus

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Moffie.

What was your experience working with the author of the memoir on which the film is based?

Oliver Hermanus: The first thing I did, when I was certain I would tackle it, was I met with [author Andre Carl van der Merwe] a few times. And he was very aware, and very comfortable, with the idea that we didn’t want him to write the script for the film. And he was very happy with us to take it and run. And we really did run! The book and the film are vastly different. What I took out of the book was the context and the setting of the apartheid machine that was indoctrinating these boys, these teenagers. And I kind of pivoted the focus to that, and reduced the love story that was quite strong and prominent in the book. I shifted it into something very subtle and quiet. But he was happy for me to do that.

what made those men the way that they are?

What did you have to learn about the period in order to make this film?

OH: On one level of course, understanding the military is just a huge challenge. Making military films is like entering another universe, there’s so much you have to learn. And this is an extinct military, so everything about it is no longer current. So there was that level of it. But then in terms of the details, the texture of conscription, and the context of the war with Angola, was all very dense and I had to read and understand it. And it’s something that was not being reported on at the time. The kind of cold-war that was going on then— what we refer to colloquially as “The Border War,” the Namibian War of Independence, the government was intentionally not reporting on it. It was kind of happening quietly. At the time, the average South African wan’t fully aware of the details. All of the details kind of came out at the end of apartheid, when we had the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and when there was this kind of investigation into what exactly was the nature of that conflict. So that’s why most South Africans were sort of… grey on the details. The only people who really knew about this war were the men who had to serve, and who had to fight, and pretty much all of them never speak about it. So I found that to be equally fascinating. And I went to Namibia, I went to visit all the camps, I became very forensic in just getting a sense of where this all took place and what that world looked like, because I had to recreate all of that in Cape Town!

The music is such a powerful force in the film. Can you discuss your approach?

OH: I think I somehow imagined this film as an opera, if that makes any sense? So the sort of brief to the composer was, “how do we do opera without voices?” In terms of creating a score that almost felt like a soundscape, it felt like a sort of representation of the time period and of the fear. Particularly for the first twenty minutes of the film it’s actually sort of one piece of music that starts at the very first frame of the film, and kind of dips out after the first scene and then comes back as the train sequence unfolds. And we sort of saw that as the tonal spirit of the music in the film. And then to constantly be contrasting that. I constantly wanted to contrast that using the Vivaldi, and the Schubert, and then Summer Breeze… just constantly adjusting the expected tone of the film as we went. Which was risky, to say the least.

How do you think this film fits into the current conversation happening around the world regarding rights for traditionally oppressed people?

OH: The film premiered in Venice, and on the day it was first shown, at the same time, it happened to be the biggest march against gender-based violence in South African history. There had been the George Floyd murder in America… we had a similarly horrifying experiences in South Africa. A young woman was murdered in a post office, and her murder just sort of shocked the whole country, and it was this senseless killing. And it mobilized women in South Africa within a week to organize a sort of national protest. So the life of Moffie as a film, in terms of an audience seeing it, started on this day of all days, and obviously the film deals with themes (toxic masculinity, whiteness) on the same day that a march was taking place in South Africa against these exact concepts. And as the pandemic has unfolded, and as we’ve seen what’s been happening in America with Black Lives Matter, and how we’ve all been kind of sitting at home, having to acknowledge and participate in some kind of seismic change… it has been an interesting journey for Moffie, because you know, I think my fascination in wanting to make the film was always in exploring this other part of my history, which is the fact that I’ve never considered the world from the perspective of a white person who oppressed my family historically, and why they would do that, what made those men the way that they are, the way that they were. And I think we are now in a space, politically and socially around the world, where we’re having to come to the intersection of these kinds of questions.