Q&A with Pedro Kos and Shawnee Isaac Smith

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Rebel Hearts.

How did the project begin and how did you two come together?

Shawnee Isaac Smith: I’ll start since it was twenty-one years ago when I met one of the Immaculate Heart sisters and was so inspired by their story that it stuck in my head like “someone has to do a movie about this, it’s amazing.” Having been brought up Catholic, I was inspired by women in the church and how they stood in their own power. That stuck with me when I met somebody who was a former IHM (Sister of the Immaculate Heart of Mary) and I said would you mind introducing me to these women, and asking if you can stand in for me as a reference to do this doc. So I started filming them and they welcomed me into their community and shared their stories and their vulnerabilities and their pain and suffering. I got to know some courageous women that continue to inspire me to this day. I carried the footage and the stories and maintained those relationships for years but couldn’t find funding to direct it myself. Later on, one of our producers, Kira Carstensen, said I can put together a team for you to make this happen. She introduced me to Pedro and it’s funny because I always assumed if I didn’t direct, it would be a woman. But Pedro had such an amazing background in Catholicism and the understanding of this order, and as he’s said, it went into his heart as well as mine. It felt like a great symbiotic relationship.

Pedro Kos: When Kira and Shawnee approached me with the story, it was like an arrow through my heart. Having had my own issues with the institution of the church as well, this story was a breath of fresh air and really captured my imagination while speaking to the moment we were living in. With each day and month and year after I came on board, it felt even more current as a story about this awakening of these oppressive structures that govern our lives. It was really a meditation on how change happens. I dove in and began spending time with some of these incredible women and filming a bit as well. Shawnee was extraordinary in capturing the firsthand accounts that she had mentioned and the materials she had collected. And then we continued to dig and unearthed some hidden gems and that’s how it came together.

It was really a meditation on how change happens.

It’s amazing to hear this was a twenty-one-year timeline with all the older interviews. Was there a sense of urgency because of how long this project has been in motion?

SIS: When I initially made the agreement with the community, I promised them that I’d interview all the elders for their archives, even if it was a story I didn’t want to use in the film. It was heartbreaking for me—and still is—whenever one of them passed away because I had always envisioned them getting a standing ovation in front of an audience for who they were. We lost Patrice Underwood, the one at Selma, right before we launched at Sundance.

PK: Because it’s taken so long, many of the greats are no longer with us.

SIS: Each year I’d say, this is the year the documentary has to come out, we need this! In retrospect now, I can’t think of a better time for it to come out. So many of the issues have come full circle and there’s a whole generation that can be inspired by these women now. Pedro and I saw that in the editing room where we saw young editors that wanted to meet these amazing women. It was so heartening to see that they were touching the younger generation as well as the generation that lived that time and that experience.

There’s an extraordinary amount of archival footage in the film. What was the process like unearthing it all?

SIS: I had some of it, but then Pedro brought in a great archival partner, Gabriella Ricketts, who was an amazing spelunker of the archival world and able to find all sorts of amazing treasures.

PK: It’s like a treasure hunt. We kept digging and Gabriella was our lead Sherlock Holmes. Because a lot of this material is from decades ago, sometimes you have to follow clues to unearth things. Usually, you start with your main suspects—the networks and newspapers—but also follow the trail of personal photographs and connections. So you might have a photograph of this person or that person, or guess who was filming here or there. Shawnee was also able to contact filmmakers. The Immaculate Heart community was very much a cultural hub in the 1960s. Their students were vibrant and they also had a very vibrant adult education section, so plenty of people were coming and taking courses. Filmmakers and lots of artists too. There were filmmakers like Baylis Glascock, Thomas Conrad, Haskell Wexler, and they were filming what was going on and the different happenings at the college. They were very generous with their works and we were able to tap into that as well. It’s really a combination of so many different elements. And we discovered within the Immaculate Heart archives audio recordings of their meetings, correspondence, notes… we tried to make this as an immersive experience as possible. I kept using the word tactile, like put me there from the sounds that you’re hearing to the visuals. We tried to bring all these disparate elements together with the animation and the graphics as cohesively as possible.

SIS: One of the interesting little archival finds we had found was that Cardinal McIntyre had a bit of a speech impediment. So he never wanted to be on camera and we couldn’t find any archival footage. Finally we found that one little bit that was a goldmine for us, since we had never heard what he sounded like.

That’s so interesting; I was wondering why he wasn’t covered more heavily in the film that way.

SIS: He also didn’t have the theology that the Immaculate Heart women did. He was not that well educated theologically so he was a little insecure in that area as well. He came from a stockbroker background.

Pedro, what it was it like coming into  and editing a project that had been in the works for so many years already?

PK: It was both thrilling and daunting to do justice to this incredible story and this wonderful material and I’m eternally grateful to Shawnee for welcoming me into the family. We really bonded with this common vision of how to tell this immersive story. We were both really inspired by these women and by Corita’s art bringing this major cohesive element in how we told the story and how to create this roller coast ride. In a way, they were part of their time, they wanted to be a part of the world and their work, what they were doing especially with creative art was a character. And in a way, it communicates with our time too, with our current moments. Usually before a project like this I put together a sizzle reel and we went out and tried to bring on new resources and partners and geared up for the full edit a few years ago. I just kept digging, and there was a wealth of riches. Shawnee did, I think, fifty interviews. There are some extraordinary women that didn’t make into the film. We joke that we could have made a ten-part miniseries and still would’ve had footage on the cutting room floor.  

Q&A with Theo Anthony

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of All Light, Everywhere.

When police capture footage with their body cameras, they are essentially engaging in filmmaking of a sort we’ve never seen before. In this film, you approach the issue from all sides, and even insert yourself into the story directly. Can you talk about that decision, and how you thought about the various meta elements of the project?

Theo Anthony: That idea of accounting for the act of observation in observing is something that I’ve always been drawn to, as a big science nerd! I’m still a science nerd; I love math and sciences. A lot of my inspiration comes from my experience in those fields. In terms of the “meta” nature of the film, I knew we were making a film about cameras, that we were going to be talking about cameras, and obviously I was making the film with a camera. So, yeah, there was really no separation, like, “here’s a meta moment.” There was no breaking the fourth wall, because there was no wall! We were just trying to describe the artifice from the start, and to do so without having any illusions about our own involvement. There’s clear acknowledgement throughout that we were bringing our own artifice and point of view to the screen, just as the body cameras do. I think that was our goal the whole time. But I will say that, you know, I think that there was a moment – a much “cleaner” version of this cut – where I was not as much of a presence in it. We had all of these really well choreographed scenes that we spent a lot time planning, and it moved very dream-like from scene to scene. And I think that, just sitting with it more and more, and just the nature of the subject matter (surveillance, policing, and etc.), obviously what’s happening in the news every single day, and in particular the murder of George Floyd last summer… it made us realize that all of these ideas we were talking about needed to be grounded in a very material, concrete way. That meant that I, personally, had to be in the film. Because having me in it was also implicating myself explicitly instead of just implicitly. It helped ground the film, and made it clear I wasn’t trying to remove myself from critique, which I think would have been very hypocritical, given what we’re talking about here with body cameras and surveillance. That was something that we just had to embrace, to really be true to the spirit of this film.

I think that these people really believe that they’re doing the right thing.

Access is crucial for any documentary, but for this film it was even more remarkable, given the vast range of people and types of environments you shot it. Can you discuss your approach and philosophy?

TA: Every section in the film, with the exception of the one community meeting scene, was preceded by months if not years of emailing back and forth, and really doing my research to see what else had been done, to see what other types of interviews they had granted, and just to always sort of pitch ourselves along the lines of what we knew they already felt comfortable doing. With Axon, for instance, you can go on YouTube and look at Steve [Tuttle’s] interviews and he has basically done everything he does in our film before – maybe not in the same sequence, but he has his whole performance, and he has his whole thing. We felt that his performance, in which he sort of channels this corporate identity, was the purest form of the argument for Axon’s cameras that we could present, and we really put a lot of faith in our audiences to receive that and critique it for themselves. There’s another style where you sort of try to trip him up, or back him into a corner… and that’s just not what we do, with anyone, regardless of whether or not I personally agree with them or not. From an even wider perspective than that, though, I think the thing to understand is that a lot of these surveillance companies, all these military-industrial companies that are retrofitted for the civilian market… the way that the pitch themselves is always about “transparency,” and that you’ll get a better understanding because you’ll be able to see these things, and once you see these things, you’ll be able to act on them, and hold these institutions accountable. And that’s great in theory but it never works in practice. In the end… what does “transparency” even mean? There’s a lot of great writing on this, Kate Crawford and Mike Ananny have this amazing piece that I always try to plug, called “Seeing without knowing: Limitations of the transparency ideal and its application to algorithmic accountability.” Kate has done some amazing work in the field of A.I. ethics, and things like that. So, yeah, with “transparency,” what they’re essentially always pitching is, “we think transparency is great,” which is true, but we always respond with, “well, we’d love you to be transparent about how this process of transparency is going.” At which point they usually say, “great,” and we’re in. Because I think they really believe it, you know? I mean, Steve wakes up every morning– I mean, he was a nice person to us. Which doesn’t excuse anything! But at the same time, he was perfectly nice to us. I think that these people really believe that they’re doing the right thing. So I think that when you approach someone with good faith, even if you don’t necessarily agree with what they’re doing, I think there’s a lot space to work with there. Or, if they deny our request to access – after we ask them to show off the transparency they’re supposedly engaging in – they’re really being flat-out hypocritical. You know, we filmed this in 2017. And that was the beginning of the Trump years. And I don’t think that a lot of the things we did then would necessarily work any more. I’ve spoken with a lot of journalist friends of mine who feel that, in the last four years alone, there’s been such a trend towards every corporation having their own PR company, their own in-house production company… and that the line between “sponsored content” and “journalism” has been obfuscated for a long time, and it’s only getting more so. If there ever was a line to begin with! I think that people have really wised-up to the old muckraking journalist in their midst.

There is a statement made in the film that police body cameras are only meant to show the officer’s perspective, and that showing anything outside of that one perspective would be problematic. There is no discussion about getting at the objective truth of a situation, which seems wrong somehow.

TA: Well, that’s very intentional– that’s supreme court-derived jurisprudence at work. To get in the weeds for a second, “use of force” policy has a very involved legal framework around it. What constitutes a “justifiable use of force” in the United States is determined by a standard known as “objectively reasonable,” which was established by a case, Graham v. Connor, in which a pair of police officers beat up a diabetic Black man who was having an episode in a bodega. The officers claimed that use of force was justified because they didn’t know he was having a diabetic episode at the time. So what the supreme court said was, well, these cops had no idea that this man was in medical danger; he was behaving erratically. So therefore they were justified in their use of force. That man lost that case against the police officers. And now that’s the law of the land. So when we talk about “objectively reasonable,” which basically means the use of 20/20 hindsight is not allowed, the way that these bodies cameras are designed is to never go beyond that “objectively reasonable” framework. You never want to show anything more than what the police officer could have known at the time. If you look at what local officials and politicians are telling you about these cameras, or what Steve is telling you about these cameras… the reality is a far cry from the notion of the “all-seeing eye of God” that this body camera supposedly represents, if you listen to them. It’s actually just a really, really crystalized enshrinement of the police officer’s incredibly limited perspective. But it’s not just due to Axon. It’s the entire court system that has deeply adopted the outcome of Graham v. Connor. I think there’s some really cool work right now to elevate the standard from “objectively reasonable” to “necessary and proportional.” This new standard says that, in order for a use of force to be justified, it can’t just be, “oh, we didn’t know at the time,” instead you have to ask the question, “was it actually necessary to break that person’s leg? Was that action proportional to the threat being posed to the officer?” And that’s not all that needs to happen, but stuff like that just seems so common sense. It’s a really uphill battle, but it’s starting to happen in different jurisdictions, which is definitely a welcome development.

Q&A with Michael Barnett, Alex Schmider and Clare Tucker

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Changing the Game.

Michael, I understand you came to the project when a friend shared that they had a child that was transgender. How important was it to make this film in order to become that much more of an advocate for marginalized people?

Michael Barnett: When I was approached by people that I care very deeply for, and as they navigated what this meant for them and for their family, I suddenly realized that my notion of what it means to be supportive needed to be interrogated a bit deeper. As I went on this journey, I very quickly realized that I didn’t understand much of what they brought to me and I really needed to investigate and educate myself, and get to work in order to sharpen my own knowledge and empathy and sharpen my own tools to be there to support and provide a little love for this family. Initially the point of it wasn’t to make a film. The goal was to go to work and be an ally and advocate as supportively as possible. And that’s when I came across Mack Beggs’ story. His story was compelling to me because at the moment I discovered it, it was helping me contextualize a lot of the work I was trying to do. It had a specificity to it that a lot of people found complex. I started unpacking it in real time before it kind of blew up and became such a big debate.  But again, the objective wasn’t to make a film but to contextualize and learn as much as I could. And then the more I thought about it, the more I couldn’t shake Mack. His story was starting to crescendo in the media and I brought it to Clare [Tucker, producer], my creative partner, and we started talking about what it would look like. The complexity of making the film didn’t lie in Mack’s story because we knew what we wanted to say; the complexity of it lied in us as a filmmaking team. Before we reached out to Mack, we called Alex [Schmider, producer], who was working in transgender media representation at GLAAD and we wanted to start a very hard conversation and challenge ourselves. Should we make this film? Should it be us? Should the film exist? Do you want to be a part of this or know someone that does? And that’s when it began for real, when Alex signed on. And then we tried to proceed as sensitively and cautiously as possible.

people need to see who they’re legislating against

Alex, what was your reaction when this film was brought to you?

Alex Schmider: My reaction working at GLAAD and seeing a lot of different projects from well-meaning, well-intentioned cisgender people was that I was very hesitant and skeptical because often the intentions aren’t there to tell accurate and authentic stories about the community. So when I got a cold call from Clare and Michael, I had a lot of questions and I also began reckoning with my own personal discomfort around the subject. We are all educated under the same media blanket and I started realizing that I had a lot of discomfort that I needed to work through. Immediately upon meeting and talking to Michael and Clare, I knew that these were filmmakers that were committed to returning these stories to these young people. And were also committed, as I was, to doing the internal work so that these stories really serve as sources of pride for the young people involved. So I was hesitant and cautious throughout the process, but we’ve been working together now for four and a half years. These people are my family, we’ve had very hard conversations about what makes it on screen and what doesn’t, how it does it, who is it trying to reach, and why? I do believe the film is as powerful as it is due to this trusting collaboration. I’m working with some of the best filmmakers and I’m a newbie to this world. I got to learn from them and they got to learn from me and there was just trust and openness about how we each came to the table and I think the result is a beautiful testament to how the film was created with love.

Clare, what did you feel was so important to share with the audience about the three primary subjects? I also appreciate how their adversaries stayed in the background of the film but still showed us there was work to be done.

Clare Tucker: When we first met all these kids, that was the first thing we wanted to show: that they’re kids. This is who you are talking about. These are their faces, their personalities, these are their interests and hopes and fears and dreams. Michael Alex and I, through filming and through editing threw a lot of things at the table and discussed different thematics, but the one thing that stayed consistent was that we wanted the kids to represent themselves and tell their own stories. As for that other group, it’s just as important to hear that side but the film obviously takes a stance and we obviously take a stance. It’s what these kids are up against and we did need to show that side and what it’s doing to these kids and their lives—the good, the bad, the ugly, all of it.  

So much has happened since you started this film four and a half years ago in regards to these issues.

CT: It’s interesting because as Michael explained earlier, we started this film because of this very personal story and this family he knows. We certainly never thought there was going to be a lawsuit that was going to get national attention and that state after state would have all this awful legislation. This was all before that. Our concerns were on an administration level, school to school, state to state. This was not a big topic in the news. It’s been crazy to watch what has happened the last eighteen months in terms of this topic. We had already made the film, so we really wanted to get it out there because people need to see who they’re legislating against. People need to see these kids to understand what they’re even talking about. It’s like Michael always says, it’s like arguing about a solution to a problem that doesn’t exist. We felt more and more that we needed to get this film out to the public however we could. Thankfully Hulu gave it a chance.

AS: As a trans man, working from my own discomfort throughout this whole filmmaking process and untangling all that I internalized about my personal ability to belong and be in the world, I’ve been so inspired to watch these young people knowing who they are at a such a young age and being so unapologetic and asserting themselves in how they know themselves by what they love to do. It’s been such an incredible journey to watch them grow up and come into their voices and come into their adulthood. We talk about kids… they’re young adults now! I’m so excited to see what their future holds because this next generation—fortunately through social media and films like this—are going to get to see themselves reflected and relate to these heroes and their own stories. Simultaneously we need more stories about the Grandma Nancy’s and the Ngozi’s and the Jen’s and Tom’s of the world because in order to find your path to allyship, to showing up, you have to see road maps for that. I think what’s so beautiful about the film is that we see that love and support crosses political party lines; it crosses religious lines. It crosses all of these lines that are drawn in the sand and ultimately when we get to know people as people and respect and accept them and create a world that’s safe and free for people to live, we are going to benefit and see the beauty in that, I hope.

I imagine there needs to be extra sensitivity when dealing with teens. How did you gain their trust before filming?

Michael Barnett: That was a process. We went out to Texas a year before we even brought a camera out to meet with Mack and his family. We had dozens and dozens of conversations with the family to express what our intentions were, to let them know that once the smoke cleared of all this media that we were still going to be there to tell their story through their words, as authentically as possible. And we did that with all of the families to build that trust. That’s pretty rare for us as filmmakers, to spend that much time without a camera. To just be there and be with them, and build that trust together.

Q&A with Euros Lyn

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Dream Horse.

What were some of the bigger challenges you faced in making this film?

Euros Lyn: One of the things we worked very hard on, as a team, was to collaborate so that every department – the production designer Daniel Taylor, Sian Jenkins the costume designer, and photography, makeup, locations – worked together very closely so that we always had a united concept of what every… so that cohesion (of color palette and of tone and of authenticity) was something that every department was constantly talking to each other about. I think, very often in film production, you can become quite siloed, and you only focus on your own work, because it’s such an enormous team; it’s hard to see across all the other departments. But we kept on talking. One of the interesting things about this project was that it was an incredibly lovely bunch of people. And we all got along socially very well. That camaraderie behind the camera very much reflects the camaraderie you see on the screen. And I think it rubs off. I think it’s there because this film is made with love by everybody who was involved with it. I’d also like to pay a lot of credit to the editor, Jamie Pearson, and the sound design team. Because those races were recorded totally without sound. Because when you’re shooting a horse traveling at forty miles per hour there’s a vehicle, and there’s an engine, and there’s the noise of the crew… and so every single piece of sound, every breath and every hoof and every jangle of the horse’s tack and bridle was put on afterwards by the sound design team. Their meticulous work was incredibly important to create the realism and drama of the races.

feeling like there is hope on the horizon, that we’re coming out of it at last

Can you talk a little bit about casting the animals? They are so integral to the film in every conceivable way. Not just the horses, either!

EL: I’m not from a horse racing background, so one of the first things we needed to solve in pre-production for this film was how we were going to make these races feel as truthful and as honest and as exciting and as dramatic as possible. And one of the first things we did was approach a company called The Devil’s Horsemen, who are the people who supplied horses for Game of Thrones, and kind of… you know, they’ve been around for decades, doing some of the best British film work. We had a fantastic horse master named Tom [Cox] who advised us on how we might approach the horse racing from a filming perspective. So what we did in the end, we had to cast thirty thoroughbred race horses in order to play ten horses on screen. And we kept them in a rotation so that they never got tired, and we only ever shot stretches of two furlongs (which is about four hundred yards) at a time, in order to keep them completely out of harms way. They were never at any risk. So that was a huge logistical challenge, to kind of break every race down into those little chunks and to schedule them. We shot all the races in about six days, which was… it was like a military operation! And my Director of Photography, Erik Wilson, and first assistant director Peter Bennett, were absolutely invaluable in kind of piece together this huge bible of paperwork that every camera team on the racing track could then kind of understand that at 9am, they were going to be at point A, and 9:40am they were going to be at point B, shooting this shot on the horses… and that’s how we managed it. But the rest of the cast of animals – the ducks, the dogs, the goat – they were all local and came from South Wales. The wolfhound that’s in the opening frame of the film, lying on the bed, he was actually the least cooperative of all the animals! As long as he had to lay down, he was fine. But the rest of the time, it involved a lot of patience… and on the actors part as well, actually, to kind of coax him into the right place.

What was the timeline for this film, from first being conceived to premiere?

EL: I first got involved about five years ago, when Katherine Butler had been talking to Neal McKay, the writer, and she got in touch with me and she asked if I’d be interested in being involved. Which I instantly said yes to, because it was a story that I knew. It was a story that had been in the press, and it kind of captured the public imagination, and had almost become a myth at that point. So it was a story I knew, but about five years ago, it must have been not long after the Brexit vote in the U.K., and Trump had been elected in the States, and there was this air of division, and divisiveness, all around. And it felt like a story that needed to be told in response to those events. A story about people coming together, wanting to do something good for its own sake. They didn’t want to make money; this wasn’t about creating a business in order to make loads of cash and to let them escape their normal lives. This was about doing something just for the sake of it. And in so doing, kind of actually forming, and strengthening, the sense of community and of togetherness. And we screened it – the premier was at Sundance, which was a year and a half ago (Sundance 2020), and we could hear the stories coming out of China, and there was talk of the virus, and so there was something… there were dark clouds gathering on the horizon when we first screened it. But nobody could have imagined that this would have laid our society so low, and caused so much pain and so much grief for so many people. And it seems strange now, that here is a story about a group of underdogs, about people who have suffered this enormous adversity, coming together, overcoming these challenges, and coming out the other side and celebrating their common humanity, celebrating these things and qualities that are inspiring and good about us as human beings. And it felt like it was about being alive, and being human in a very important way. I hadn’t watched the film, myself, for a good year, until a couple of weeks ago! And watching it again… I felt emotional, I felt the tears coming. In part that was informed by this experience we’ve all been through, with COVID. And now feeling like there is hope on the horizon, that we’re coming out of it at last. And hopefully this is a film that will speak to audiences about the possibility, about the amazing possibility, of humans when we come together to do something good as a community.

Q&A with Michael Rianda, Phil Lord and Christopher Miller

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of The Mitchells vs the Machines.

This film has been long in the making and is clearly a heartfelt project. Mike, can you tell us how it all started?

Michael Rianda: Sony had approached me about making a movie and because these movies take so long, I thought what can I make that I already have in mind? I have this burning furnace of love in my heart for my family. They’re sort of eccentric and strange and I would always connect to people when I talked about my family because I think everyone secretly thinks their family is nuts but they don’t want to admit it. But as soon as I’d admit it, everyone was like, oh yeah great mine too! I tell this story a lot, but my dad really is a nature-loving crazy person and once he woke me up at five in the morning and was like “Mike, wake up, we gotta build these bathtubs in the middle of the woods so we can legally be naked in nature, right?!” I had no idea what he was talking about and my mother was like, “he saw it on a Viagra commercial.” And the crazy thing was that he actually built them, and everyone thought he was nuts, and I thought he was nuts, but whenever anyone saw the tubs they were like, Brian these are incredible. I realized in those moments and my dad’s commitment to making them that he’s really a crazy person making these tubs against all logic, and I’m a crazy person making cartoons against all logic. Suddenly I felt close to him and found a kind of empathy for my parents that made me see them as humans for the first time. One of the reasons for the movie is that I was finally able to sort of see parenting through their eyes.

Phil Lord: I’m curious about your father’s understanding of the law. He’s not a lawyer, is he?

MR: He’s not a lawyer! And he’s also like “I don’t own this land but I have a handshake deal with John Harrington wink wink.” So he built these on someone else’s land?! “Don’t worry about it,” he told me.

PL: I understand the way common-law works is that if you put a tub in a field that you own that land. Once you take a bath, it’s yours!

Christopher Miller: And that led somehow to you making a movie about your family AND a robot apocalypse.  

MR: And the robot apocalypse came because it was funny for me to imagine a character like my dad dealing with technology because he loves nature so much. As a kid I loved robots, and as an adult I became really fascinated by the idea that robots and AI can do some of the same things we can do now. And if that’s the case, what is it about humanity that perseveres and is worth saving. The collaborations we have with one another, they’re hard but worth fighting for.

It was really trying to reflect our own teenage enthusiasm about film

The family element is so crucial. The pacing of the film is wonderful and allows that disconnect between Katie and Rick to breathe. As producers, how did you advocate for this type of pacing in the film?

PL: We met Mike in the hallways of Sony animation. There was this energy seeping into the hallways and we looked into his office and saw piles of papers, no empty surfaces, and we were like, oh, this reminds us of us. Chris and I make a lot of densely-paced, tightly-packed movies. If you can believe it, things like The Lego Movie at one point moved even faster and we’ve learned some things over time. There’s a famous story about an early test screening of The Lego Movie where a passionate collaborator said “this movie is too long, we need to take ten minutes out,” and we realized the reason it felt long was because people didn’t have enough time to engage. So we said no problem, yes sir, we’re going to take ten minutes out, and then we secretly put ten minutes into the movie and it allowed you to watch characters make choices and take in information and think before they acted and it actually made the movie play a million times faster. In this movie we spent a lot of time working with Mike and his team trying to make the emotional storytelling really land so that we could have a crazy Furby attack sequence and it would be welcomed by the audience instead of a distraction. What Mike has done so beautifully is take all these zany things and given them meaning in the family, which when we tested the movie was the thing that was indestructible.

CM: From the beginning, the family felt personal and the story felt really emotional and the creativity and density of the comedy was undeniable. It was about shaping it in a way that really allowed the audience to engage with all sides and all members of the family, where there was a real growth arc for everybody. The great thing about Mike and Jeff [Rowe, co-director] is that they were so willing to try a million things and they were never satisfied. If we suggested moving something or trying something new, they always had great ideas and they’d try anything to make it better than it was before. And they never gave up until it finally came out on Netflix. And even then, they were still adding bits and trying and were overflowing with energy and passion.

MR: We made a mistake early on with Chris and Phil where we were like “we want this to be the greatest animated movie of all time and we want to it to be really grounded and wonderful!” and then they unfortunately held us to those wild claims.

You employ so many wonderful pop-culture references to appeal to those old and young from Portrait of a Lady on Fire to T2. These are such great marriages of ideas. How did you balance that?

MR: In the whole movie, we’re trying to be observational and true to our own experiences. Me and Jeff went to film school and were jacked-up teenagers who were like, we’re going to study every Paul Thomas Anderson movie! We were trying to tap into that fervor for film and what someone growing up right now would be excited about. We had just seen Portrait of a Lady on Fire and it was amazing and it really seemed like Katie would love it. We looked at the type of people we worshipped at her age and thought about who Katie would worship. It was really trying to reflect our own teenage enthusiasm about film. I made these goofy Criterion Collection knockoff films, so I had Katie do it. We wanted to embrace our memories about that passion.

PL: In cinema culture, the distinction between what’s highbrow and lowbrow has sort of collapsed, right? You’re on film twitter and people are like, Demolition Man is a masterpiece! And we’re born of that theory that you can love a crazy silly movie and that it is cinematic, and so is a French drama about nineteenth-century lovers on an island. You can have an appetite for both and they can both inform a young filmmaker.

CM: It’s also not like Mike and Jeff and us were sitting in a room and trying to pick jokes that would appeal to this demographic or that demographic. We would find things that would appeal to us or make us laugh, or try to put it through the lens of what we think the character would say or feel. There was never data science and trying to fit these references into boxes; it was more about amusing ourselves.

MR: That was the big rule—does it make us laugh? And since we’re man-children, we cover all spectrums!

PL: Since we’re so immature, we match up pretty well with kids. I like that her taste in movies kind of legitimizes her crazy dog films as art. She’s not making them to get clicks; she’s making them because she thinks they are great works of art.

Mike, this is your first feature but you’ve been working in animation for a long time. I looked at your first short and it is so incredibly uncanny how it’s a spiritual cousin of this film. Can you talk about developing your voice?

MR: I think finding your voice is really difficult. I do think when I was younger, it was really through a process of failing that I found my voice. I would do things that were too goofy or too slapstick, or on the other hand, too personal and uncomfortable. I had to find a balance because I had sort of comedy Tourette’s where I desperately wanted people to think I’m funny. Then I would try to balance that with a story that people actually cared about. In that short, the impetus was that I was working at a job that drove me insane. I was doing data entry at the Monterey Bay Aquarium, which is a wonderful place but data entry is not a wonderful job. So I worked at the aquarium and everyone had stars in their eyes like, do you feed the fish? And I was like, no I enter people’s names into the membership bank! But in both films, I was trying to take this kernel of truth. In the movie it’s about family and in the short it was about working and finding your passion. And then I was trying to tell both of them in the most entertaining way that’s as funny as possible but also as true as possible. Try to fit those two things together is where I got my voice.