Q&A with Stephen Chbosky, Ben Platt, Julianne Moore, Amy Adams, and Amandla Stenberg

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Dear Evan Hansen.


Stephen, you’re no stranger to bringing musicals to the big screen, and you’re no stranger to stories about teenage longing and discontent. How did you get involved in the project?

Stephen Chbosky: I saw the show about three years ago, on Broadway. And I loved it. I didn’t know anything about it when I saw it. And I loved the show. And so the next day I called my team and I just said, “look, I don’t know if they’re going to make a movie of this, but if they do, I’d love to meet about it.” And a couple months later, I had some conversations with the producers, and I kept asking, and I kept pestering. And your question is sort of how I pitched myself— I remember going to Universal, and meeting with the executives and I saying, “I’ve basically done two things for the last fifteen years of my career: Musicals, and thoughtful films about young people.” So, I’m you’re guy. And luckily they agreed! That’s how I got involved. The vision was, really… I was obsessed with all the different ways that I felt like you could capture the emotions of the show, but in a very literal medium like film. And that included live singing. There several very specific moments in the show that I was very moved by, and I talked about how I would show them on film. For example, something like the song Requiem. It was beautifully depicted on the stage with three people, and I thought, well, with the family, what do each of those three spotlights mean? And I started to talk about how the abstraction of the stage would translate to the real world.

I really knew that the key to the lie is her need.

Ben, you’ve lived with this character for years. How did you adapt Evan’s character for film, and what was it like coming back to him after having several years off?

Ben Platt: It was certainly terrifying, a little bit scary, to re-enter that space that had been such a formative experience for me, both in personal terms (it obviously really changed my life in many ways), and then in a mental sense, to enter that anxious and somewhat self-hating mind space that Evan lives in for a lot of the movie was a scary thing to go back to. But I think just the prospect of how many people would be seeing the film, and could be positively affected by the story — after seeing firsthand how lives change and conversations start with this piece — it was more than enough motivation to get back in the shoes, literally! I think the translation was mostly about internalizing things, and demodulating things, and keeping all of the essences of his fraught emotional state, and his hunched posture, and his ticks (pulling on his clothes, biting his nails, taking up as little space as possible)… all of those instincts from the stage had to be kept in tack — they’re things that I feel really specify who Evan is, and that make him a specific person — but just trusting the intimacy of the camera and of the medium to not need to broadcast things in such a heightened way. And Stephen was a fantastic, consistent reminder of how to kind of bring things closer to the ground, and to keep it “inside the bottle,” as he would say. And in terms of singing, we had the great opportunity to sing a lot of the music live. And so there was a nice sort of raw communicative quality to it that the musical already has, but kind of to the nth degree for the film. So I think, for me, vocally the priority became even less the beauty of the music (which is there already), and the sort of quality of the singing, and more so just the communication of the emotions and the forwarding of the narrative. And that was really fun. Especially as a musical movie nerd for my whole life, and musicals in general, to see one that’s so sincere and so fully realized in terms of the humans singing and communicating in real spaces and in real rooms… it was really exciting to be part of a movie like that. 

Amy, how did you find the character, and how did your musical training influence your approach? 

Amy Adams: I was introduced to the play a little late in the game— I saw it in 2019 in person. And I just fell in love with the piece. I was so profoundly moved by the experience of all the characters. I immediately said to my agent, “if they ever do a film of this, I just want to be involved in whatever way I can.” So when I had the opportunity to develop this with this amazing group of people — to work with Ben, Amandla, Julie and Kaitlyn, Stephen… everybody! I could keep going on. It was humbling. I was just so grateful. I think that coming to this character… I really knew that the key to the lie is her need. Her need to know her son, her need to believe that her son could have been more than she saw. She wanted to think that she had missed something, that there was something there that she could hold onto. So that need sort of drives the first lie. It was one of those characters that, as I played her, was really… you had to just go with where you were on the day. And working with Ben, and the entire cast, that became very… I don’t want to use the word “easy,” but it became a very immersive experience. It was so moving. Working with Danny in developing the marriage, working with Kaitlyn in developing the mother/daughter relationship (which I thought was so key to Cynthia as well)… it was a really wonderful experience, and I’m really honored, and proud to have been a part of it.

How did you develop your bond with Evan, given the abbreviated shooting schedule?

Julianne Moore: I was so incredibly moved by the show. It was a show that was important to my family, because when I saw it on Broadway, my kids were adolescents. And this speaks so much to the adolescent experience, about feeling like you need to grow up, and kind of announce to the world who you are, and present that at a time when you don’t even know that fully yourself. It was so beautiful… my kids listened to these songs constantly in the car! What really struck me about it was, as much as it’s about an adolescent experience, it’s also about a parental experience, about what you go through as your child starts to differentiate themselves. You know that they need that distance, but you’re trying to be present, and be available to them whenever possible. And in her situation — I was really really moved by Heidi, because she’s a single parent and this is a tiny tiny family, there’s just the two of them — and so, as much as she’s trying to do everything (provide for him by herself), she’s also not physically there that she needs to be. And in the moment when she sings that song, that’s what’s so beautiful about it: That’s the time where she says, “I want to communicate to you how much I love you, how important you are to me, and how aware I was that I was going to make these terrible mistakes. And I have. That doesn’t mean that I love you any less.” And even though we didn’t have a lot of rehearsal, but I think Ben and I were both excited by the relationship, and wanted to connect as much as possible. And because our scenes are just the two of us — there’s like, nobody else there — I think we had that time to kind of establish their rhythm and their relationship, and just sort of go for it. You have to; you have no alternative. You have the time that you’re given. With that being said, I think it’s profoundly written. I love the book, I love the music. It’s very… as an actor, you have a lot to lean in to, as well as all these other cast members and our great director. So it was the infrastructure of everything that was the most helpful to me.

“So Big / So Small” was such an incredibly moving number.

JM: Yeah. That song is… I mean, it’s the ultimate parental song. It really is. It’s kind of… it floors you, I think, when you realize that this person hasn’t revealed themselves at all to you, you don’t know anything about her, you really don’t know anything about their history… and there’s this one moment, when she decides her son is able to hear it, she reveals herself in this way. And it’s just kind of intimate, and crazy, and emotional… and it’s a gift of a song for an actor, it really is.

Amandla, your character (Alana) was a bit different than the one we met on the stage. How did you grapple with the character as she was written, and can you discuss the song you composed for the film, “The Anonymous Ones.”

Amandla Stenberg: The Alana that I saw on the page was already very different from the stage version. She has this moment of vulnerability where she’s really struggling with her mental health, and that’s a reason why she connects so deeply to Evan, and also why she has such an impetus to start the Carter project. So I think going into portraying her, it was about really trying to tap into who that kid is, who is overachieving, and performing at such a high level… but is also struggling at the same time. And for me, it kind of really became about tapping into her self-worth, and the way that she valued herself. For me, that meant that she really needed a lot of external validation in order to compensate for the ways in which she maybe felt like she wasn’t fully whole. So I feel like, in terms of her physicality, and the way that she spoke… it felt important to me to portray a kid who wasn’t fully comfortable in her skin yet. And so I think she’s kind of different in that way. But also, I think Stephen Levenson kind of supplemented some of the main themes of the musical with kind of a new angle: there are a lot of people who you wouldn’t anticipate are going through mental struggles. It’s such a universal experience to have those kinds of challenges. So it was, for me, kind of about leaning into that feeling, and that’s what we decided to focus on most with the song, because we wanted to provide another opportunity for the kids who loved Dear Evan Hansen so much, and who connect to it, and who need it as a place to feel seen and heard, to also feel represented by this character. So that’s why she’s kind of different, why she feels different… and why she’s also this really high-energy overachiever! I think we just had a lot more time and space to hopefully add more color to her. And so the song is about what it’s like to be someone who presents themselves with a particular facade, but who is actually struggling. And how that’s actually something that most of us are going through, to one extent or another.

Q&A with Natalie Morales and Mark Duplass

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Language Lessons.

You both had so many roles in making this film. How did you two connect to make this film during Covid?

Mark Duplass: Natalie and I were acquaintances; friends of friends who had met a few times and I think we had the sense that we respected each other’s work and we had hit it off and liked each other. I knew I wanted to work with her and ideally share the screen with her at some point, and we hadn’t really had that opportunity. A couple of years ago I asked Natalie if she wanted to direct a few episodes of my anthology show Room 104, that I was doing for HBO. She knocked those out of the park so that just made me want to work with her even more. Then at about two months into the pandemic, I was feeling a little creatively frustrated and doing a bunch of writing and thought I’ll just squirrel away a bunch of scripts for when the world opens back up to make them in a normal way. But I didn’t want to wait to make something. I was taking Spanish lessons online with an institute in Guatemala, and it was a weird time. We were all dealing with fragility… one of my close friends Lynn Shelton had just passed away. Neither of us were in the mood for small talk so the conversation went deep pretty quickly. And I was surprised at how a connection could form over this sort of video chat format. I thought there was something there in that relationship so I called Natalie immediately and asked her if she spoke good Spanish. And she responded “oui,” which I thought was really awesome.

Natalie Morales: I can’t remember if I did say that or if you just made that up and now I believe it.

MD: I think you did, or maybe it was in a text.

NM: I have been known to be somewhat witty at some points.

MD: And a little sarcastic.

NM: I had directed those episodes of Room 104 but Mark was busy doing one of his thousand other projects so he wasn’t actually on set when I directed. So we had never worked together in a capacity where we were together all the time. It was exciting to get to do that with him, and I always wanted to work with Mark and Jay and their company, but to do so in an ultra-intimidate way, with something coming out of both of our hearts and brains together was very exciting.

what you see in this film is the consummation of the early stages of our platonic relationship deepening

Can you describe the early writing process?

NM: Mark, correct me if I’m wrong, but I think that once Mark called me and asked if I spoke Spanish, we were both like okay, now we need to write something! And we paused, and then I suggested we both go our separate ways and write bios for our characters, just to see what happens. And that is how we started. I had never done any writing that way and I really believe it paid off in this, because we were both so sure of our characters, which came in very handy not only in writing and developing the story, but also later in the improvisations we did. So we wrote the biographies for these two characters without consulting the other person, and perhaps trying to surprise the other person! Then we figured out how to merge these two people and their lives and make it interesting.

MD: The only thing I would add is that I’ve been using this term alacrity a lot in terms of how I make my art. I’ve discovered it in these kinds of discussions as I’ve gotten feedback from people and what they respond to in it. This movie is the ultimate exercise in alacrity and speed—from the minute I called Natalie to the moment we wrapped the film was about four weeks. We knew we were going shoot off of an outline, mostly, and we knew we were going to want to script some of the more intricate Spanish stuff because my character Adam speaks a little better Spanish that I do personally. We needed to make sure we had all that right for Natalie and her character Cariño. But otherwise, we felt very confident in our ability to improvise the scenes together, us being the writers and the performers. Getting the story in place, like in regards to the platonic love story… I’d like to say that was something we pinpointed early on as something unique to the romantic comedy form and we were ready to raise the flag for and say we’re doing something new. We knew we wanted it to be a platonic relationship; in fact, that was one of the major motivations as to why we wanted Adam to be gay in the first place, to remove all sense of “will they or won’t they” from the table and so the audience could just focus on the intricacies of platonic love. We knew that was interesting, because Natalie and I both have deep, and in some cases deeply complicated platonic relationships. We shared that and thought that could be really cool, but we weren’t thinking “wow, this could be really trailblazing and new.” We didn’t realize that until people saw the film and reflected that back to us.

I thought it showed such restraint to have that big blowout argument at the end of the film because it’s simmering along the whole way. Both of your characters voice big and accusatory ideas. For the both of you, which of those big themes—or small themes even—did you find as the most fascinating as actors and writers?

NM: Off the top of my head, there were a lot of things we explored in this movie that were so interesting. Part of what was so freeing about making this is that we didn’t know what it would be and we didn’t know if it would be good, so it kind of left us room to explore anything that we were itching to explore. There are themes of class differences and what we assume of people. When I saw myself in the Cariño outfit with the school teacher background in this Costa Rica setting, I could see myself through the eyes of a gringo, as Cariño would say, and I could see what the assumptions you would make about her might be if you didn’t know anything about her. And I thought about the assumptions we make about all people, well-intentioned or not. As Americans, we have assumptions about people from other countries and what their lives are like, but also as people we make assumptions about everyone we meet. It’s so interesting and I’m sure they’ll continue to study this to learn about its effects, but I’ve noticed that when you meet someone in person, you do make a judgment about them the same way as you would via Zoom. But in Zoom, you get this square of like part of my house, or part of my office, this peek at people’s homes and lives and you also get this slightly exaggerated way of talking and expressing yourself that we’ve adjusted to really in just the last year and a half in order to be better understood. So we make our sentences a little clearer, like I’m doing right now, and I’m a little more smiley than I’d normally be… and then those things start to fall off because you have this familiarity of talking to someone every day, or weekly, and then the front comes down and you start to pick up on things about people. That idea was really fascinating to me. Things we assume about people and everything we project and hide, and intentionally or unintentionally show, these were all things I was interested in exploring. We also talked about movies or people with a White Savior Complex and I’ve never seen it been said or called out in a movie. It was important to me to do that and get it out there and talk about these things that are difficult to talk about.

MD: That wasn’t a central part of our plot but it was a fun side street. That was something that was interesting and exciting for me… it’s like a vulnerability thing that I have, where I talk a lot about how Duplass Brothers as a company tries to lift up struggling filmmakers and for me, that comes out of survivor’s guilt as a struggling filmmaker. I see someone struggling and I have so much PTSD and pain when I look at them that I can’t allow them to suffer. But there is an element of pity in there, and an element of judgment that is off and a little strange. And I’m trying to figure out what the right place is in that, so I was able to explore some of that stuff through Adam and his relationship with Cariño as a side angle to what that could be in my life. That was really exciting to me. I also got to explore something else that I know about myself, which is that I can come on a little strong with people when I like them and I can either intimidate them or make them back up a little bit. It’s a little bit of a blind spot I have; I can miss a social cue or two at times. I wanted to play that out with Adam to see when that could go wrong or when that could be perceived as just a puppy dog love. And there was a third thing that was important for me to explore. I’m kind of a private person; I’m married with two kids and I don’t have a lot of room in my life for a lot of big deep relationships because I work all the time. And work is a way for me to connect with people. Being able to make this movie with Natalie—who is someone I really like as a friend—was a way for me to experience that wonderful, platonic-falling-in-love energy that one gets. Normally people get that out of dating, but I’m married, I don’t have dating. So that was a fun thing that I was able to do, and what you see in this film in a lot of ways is the consummation of the early stages of our platonic relationship deepening.

Q&A with Amber Sealey, Elijah Wood and Luke Kirby

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of No Man of God.

What was your initial reaction to the script?

Elijah Wood: I came into the script about five years ago, at a film festival in Austin, Texas, called Fantastic Fest. We were seating for a film (I can’t remember what the movie was), and the writer of the screenplay leaned over — knowing my company, and the kinds of movies we’re interested in making (genre films) — and he said, “I have this script about Ted Bundy that is about a portion of Ted Bundy’s life that is not as well documented, about his relationship to Bill Hagmaier, the FBI profiler, in the last four years of his life.” And our eyes kind of darted open! And we were super-keen to read the script. And we read the script, and we were blown away by it. Particularly because it’s this sort of chilling document about something that really happened between these two men over the course of these four years. And the script was so sparse in a way, in a beautiful way… that it sort of left room for these two people to discuss what they’re discussing over this period of time. I just found it really chilling, and moving as well.

Amber Sealey: My first thought was, “another Bundy movie?” And my next thought was, “me directing a Bundy movie?” But I was intrigued because I knew of Elijah’s company, and I was obviously a fan of his work, so I read the script and then it was such an easy, smooth read… like I just tore through it. And I found that I had a take! And then I met with Daniel Noah and Elijah and pitched, and I thought, “well, we’ll see if we’re on the same page.” If we’re on the same page, this conversation might get interesting. And it did— just right away there was a kind of… chemistry that we had. And we were talking about the same kind of things that we thought were really important to put forward in the film, and why we felt it was important to make this film even though there were already so many Bundy films out there. So we were just really on the same page, and I signed on.

Luke Kirby: I was in the middle of production of a play called Judgement Day, an Ödön von Horváth play, up at the armory in New York. And that play had a lot of… there were some themes about commitment to the state, sexual confusion, religion… it had a number of things. And I read the script for No Man of God, and it also moved very smoothly, it kind of offered that compelling reading experience, just by virtue of the writing being so fluid. And there was something within the story that kind of resonated with the play that I was doing. It sort of felt like there was a theme that was kind of culturally resonant that I attributed also to the play, and it felt like this was maybe a natural progression somehow. That maybe in some ways, the character I was playing in that play (which was written during World War II) was sort of an antecedent to this character. But I was really kind of reluctant and worried about the responsibility that comes with telling a story like this, so I kind of evaded it for as long as I could! And then Amber and I met in a park in Los Angeles. It was March 16th 2020, right before everything kind of collapsed and shut down. And we were able to just have a very thorough and open and honest conversation that was not just sort of, you know… effervescent and bubbly and looking forward to working together, but was more comprehensive in terms of the actual substance of what were going to do to tell this story. And Amber had such a compelling… well, personhood! And I was sort of drawn in, and as time wore on through the land of pandemico, I got on board.

everything has a whole new appearance when you’re researching this kind of stuff

LK: In terms of getting ready, once the die is cast, you’re just sort of committed. And no matter how hard you try to move away from it, at that point you do have a job to do. So, I sort of found myself almost physically kicking and screaming within myself. I didn’t feel especially… I didn’t have a lot of appetite. There were things that were kind of infecting me that didn’t feel great, but you know, in some ways — because were were in COVID and I was quarantining with my wife, and we were put up in a house in Los Angeles, and I had a pool, and we had this kind of very quiet lifestyle and I had her as my support… And I was able to jump in the pool and sink to the bottom and scream every once in a while. But there was really no way around it kind of infecting your perspective for the duration of the shoot. One of the things I do is I go for long runs. And every dark corner, every bush, everything has a whole new appearance when you’re researching this kind of stuff. And the world feels very dangerous and very scarily alive. Even, you know, any music you listen to is going to be completely altered by what you’re thinking about. I remember listening to Leonard Cohen’s album Death of a Ladies’ Man and suddenly it had this insanely different, disgusting perspective… and I’m sure Leonard Cohen would slap me with his Zen stick for even making the connection. But yeah, it’s just an impossible thing. The good fortune was that, you know, Amber and Elijah are excellent people, and by virtue of that, the whole crew was excellent people. We were sort of in an environment that felt very comfortable, very easy, fun was very present and curiosity was very present. So I was just happy to come to work and be with people, because it had been a long time since any of us had been with anyone. It was really kind of a delight in that way.

What would you hope your audience would do, think, or feel after seeing this film?

AS: I find that when I’m making a film, if I think about, or worry about, what the audience is going to think or feel, I sort of start drowning. Because the weight of those expectations, or, you know… I guess you could call it my “hopes” for what kind of experience people will have with the movie… it feels too heavy for me to bear. So I really try to just focus on telling the truth of the story. And making it, I guess to put it simply, a film I would want to watch myself. And I always like to assume that the audience is really smart— they’re going to see things in it that I don’t even see in it. And I love the concept of, every audience member is going to bring their own story to the film. It’s all subjective, right? We love things, we hate things, we see this, we don’t see that… and I kind of love that about film, in general. Someone can love something that someone else hates. I assume that whatever it is an audience brings with them, it’s fascinating to me. I love talking about film, I love hearing what other people got out of it, what it made them think or feel, and I love answering questions and hashing things out. So, in a sense, I don’t really have any expectations. At the same time, all I can talk about is what was interesting to me about this story and this film. What’s interesting to me is that two things can exist at the same time: we can be interested in this kind of person — the Ted Bundys of the world — we can be interested in why they do what they do, and how they do what they do… and we can know that this interest is maybe glorifying people that we shouldn’t glorify, or it’s putting our attention in the wrong places. Those two things can exist together, and they both need to be looked at. So, to me, you can make an entertaining film about someone like Bundy, and you can also ask really intelligent questions at the same time. It doesn’t all have to be just gore, or other salacious stuff. I guess I just hope that people think and feel something! And that they want to talk about it, bad or good. I hope that people pay attention to where we, as a society, put our attention. I think we are trained to put our attention on certain things by the world. By our phones, and computers, and the media we consume… we are trained to look at certain things. And I always like to ask, “yeah but what about that thing, or that person, off in the corner?” So that’s what I hope it makes people think about.

EW: I think what’s really unique about the film is that it doesn’t editorialize for you. It leaves you, in the audience, with the pieces of the puzzle to put together yourself and it allows you to walk away with your own feelings of what you just witnessed, about Ted and about Bill. And I love that about the film. I love that different people take different things away from it. Those are my favorite kinds of movies— the movies that don’t necessarily have tidy conclusions. They don’t tell you what you need to feel or think; they kind of leave it open for you.

Q&A with Andreas Koefoed

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of The Lost Leonardo.

You’ve done a lot of music documentaries but I believe this is your first film based in the art world. How did you get involved?

Andreas Koefoed: A producer friend of mine got in touch and told me about this incredible story. He was in touch with this British art critic—Ben Lewis—that was writing a book about the whole affair. That was where it started. I felt like it was a really fantastic story on so many levels. The painting is discovered in 2005 for almost nothing and then twelve years later it becomes the most expensive painting ever sold, maybe even the most expensive object ever sold. That was mind-boggling. But then on top of that story, you add the whole authenticity story and that made it even more intriguing. I figured out that half of the world’s Leonardo scholars would say it is a da Vinci, and the other half would not. I felt there was potential for it to be almost like a farce, but about something that is very serious and also about human longings and the cynicism in the financial and political world of the art scene. There are so many layers to the story. So the challenge was how to fit this all into one narrative.

I felt there was potential for it to be almost like a farce

The structure is really fascinating because you introduce the journey of this painting through currency and tracking. That holds the film from the beginning as a way in for the audience.

AK: It took a long time to find the right structure and also the right way of telling the story. We knew pretty quickly that we wanted to tell it through the firsthand sources. We got in touch with the two art dealers who found it, the restorer, some of the experts, the curator at the National Gallery. But then at some point we didn’t have access to the firsthand sources like the oligarch—Rybolovlev—and especially Mohammed Bin Salman. So there we had to change the point of view a bit and go through some of the journalists and the people who had observed the story from the outside, or had dug into it as investigators. At some point we figured out that we had to deal with three different worlds that are in different ways secretive. In the first act, it was the art world, so we’d dig into the world of art dealers, restorers, experts and so on. The second world, which is the second act of the film, is the financial world. Simply by following the painting’s journey, we would automatically reach and then spend the time in the financial world and be able to look at the financial aspects of the story… the way extremely wealthy people are speculating in buying art, and how a lot of the world’s most fantastic art is locked away in freeports and lost for humanity in a way. And then in the third act, it’s the secret part of the political world where you go into that geopolitical game between nations where suddenly a painting can have big significance. In a way, the story fell really naturally into three acts. In a way it all made sense but it took us a long time to find each little story in the bigger story, and how much play should we give those stories without losing the main thread of the story—which was the painting and its increasing value. It was a difficult balance because we got interested in, for example, Bouvier’s story in the second act, or Modestini’s story in the first act. Every time we spent a little too much time with them, trying to understand their backstory or their world, then the film would kind of lose its narrative spine because we’d almost forget about the painting. So we found that every two minutes we had to go back to the painting, to the narrative spine of the story. We had five writers and researchers but it took us a long time to arrive at the final narrative structure.

How did you shoot the painting and the restoration process?

AK: It was a challenge that we weren’t there while it was actually being restored. We never got the chance to film the actual painting, so we needed to get really hi-res photos from the process and then in some cases, print and use them for re-enactments. And we were lucky that the restorer, Dianne Modestini, was willing to let us film her while she was restoring other paintings and we could use that as visualizations of her restoration process with this painting. It would have been really difficult to find an actress to do re-enactments and then jump in and out of interviews with Modestini. In a way, by just filming her in her studio working on paintings, we were able to use that as a re-enactment. Then of course we had the painting in the different stages, so we were able to show how it looked it the clean state, and how she restored it. It’s really a remarkable difference between the clean state and the finished version. Some people say that she went too far, but as I’ve understood the restoration practice, it is a fully recognized approach to restoring a painting to bring it back to how you think it originally looked, back to life so to speak. Based on the painting that is still there, you imagine how it looked originally, and that is completely recognized within the art world. But some people would say it would have been better to make it an archeological restoration, where you keep it in the clean state, but you fill out some small gaps and holes and make sure the panel is alright and so on. But there’s nothing wrong with choosing one method or the other.

Can you talk a bit about the color correction and the overall look of the film?

AK: In general, the film has a dark and blueish tone, which underlines the mystery aspect. After the first round of color correction, we had to really make the look of the film a bit more subtle, especially when it had to do with the painting because we couldn’t manipulate the colors of the painting. It had to look real and as close to the original as possible. But of course, I’ve only seen the original in a reproduction.

We tried to use the painting in different ways in the film, by letting the characters in the film being interviewed with this direct eye effect, because Christ in the painting also looks straight into your eyes. So with the different shots we tried to give the feeling of Renaissance paintings with the light and so on, by keeping the background dark and letting the person stand forward and be touched by the light. We tried to live up to da Vinci in the visual style, but of course that was impossible. It’s a documentary and we can’t control that much. But it was an inspiration. Storytelling-wise, he has this sfumato technique where he doesn’t paint clear outlines, he builds the shapes up with layers and layers, like thirty or forty layers, and then the shapes start to emerge. In a way, that resembles the story in that there are so many layers you can try to scrape off but you will never really reach any core or any truth because it’s opaque in a way. Another aspect from Leonardo’s art that we tried to reproduce in the film is that his characters are all in a movement, and they all show an intention, and you get a glimpse into their psychology. I wanted to do the same with the characters in the story. They present themselves in one way, and at the same time you get a feeling of how they are on the inside. That was a fun way of trying to implement da Vinci’s thoughts into the film, despite the questions about whether or not the painting is actually by him.

Q&A with Pascual Sisto

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of John and the Hole.

Can you discuss the way the film begins, and ends, with a family dinner scene?

Pascual Sisto: I think they are two very important scenes, but I will first say that, as a point of interest, they were shot on the same day because of practical reasons. So we had to work psychologically with the actors and we discussed everything because one scene is of course at the beginning, before they know anything that has happened, and then the other one is at the end, with all of the psychological baggage that they have with them after their experience. So it was very interesting to shoot them back-to-back, because it was almost… I talk a lot of times about these images that you see in the newspaper, “spot the differences,” and one of them has a hat, and the other one doesn’t… so it was like that, but it was for things you cannot see. So it was like comparing two images, and noticing the unseen changes in the images. So when we discussed that with the actors, they immediately got it. In the beginning we set up the scene as a normal family having dinner, they’re all very casual, they’re all looking at their phones and devices, and doing a regular every day contemporary dinner. And at the end, there are subtle differences, and of course… I wish there would be an opportunity (I hope someone on YouTube maybe will do it one day) of putting them back-to-back so you can compare the behaviors! Of course in the second scene, we are zooming out from John’s face, and I think it’s a little bit of, like, this idea that we’ve been always so focused on him and his internal world, and then slowly we reveal that he is back in this family setting, back with the family. Every time I’ve seen it (and of course I’ve seen it many times), I look at each one of the different characters, and there’s something interesting in how they all play the two scenes differently. If you notice, Brad, the father, there’s something about him… in the closing dinner scene, he’s looking at John for the most part, and they’re not saying anything, they’re not speaking, of course. But the way he looks… not that he’s respecting him more, but he obviously seems him differently in the second scene. However, the setting — for an outsider who hadn’t seen the film — would look the same. If we were walking by their window, we would probably not notice a difference between the starting and ending dinner scenes. So that, for me, is what the essence of this film is. Internally, many changes can happen, but externally things can seem to be the same.

silence is what the film is about in many ways

You’ve known the writer Nicolás Giacobone for some time, and this film is adapted from a short story he wrote. What was that process like?

PS: He loves short stories, so that’s probably his natural habitat in many ways. We have a relationship— we’ve been friends for years now. I would send him my projects — film and video projects, or art projects that I would do — and he would send me his writings, and we would trade comments back and forth. And he sent me this one. He told me later that he always had it in mind that it could potentially be a good film, and when he sent it to me I responded right away. The short story (I’ve explained this before, obviously), it was nine pages, and it was very brief and to the point. It was like bullet points, one sentence after the next, it was like a first-person diary sort of thing, all from John’s point of view. So it was like seeing through his eyes: “Today I did this, today I played PlayStation… and then I gave them some sweaters because it was cold.” And as a reader you think, “gave who some sweaters…?” So you have to piece the story together as it happens. I think eventually he changed it, because the final version was a bit different than the initial one he sent me. So that was something that was always moving forward sort of step by step. It had a lot of strange, quiet pacing to it already. And I responded to it, we started discussing it, we discussed the idea of potentially making it into a film without saying anything specific, and we never really confirmed it, but then after a few conversations he already had a first draft of a script! He’s incredible in that way. And he wrote the draft himself entirely, and then from then on we started crafting more of the shooting script, the production script, with more elements that we thought would work. So I would say it was good to know him and to be involved while he was writing it, because it allowed both of us to make it in a way that would be great for me to actually shoot.

The tone of this film is so precise and unusual. How did you control it as you were making the film?

PS: I think the most important part of that— a lot of the times we talked about this, because it’s not seen. You know, a lot of people see John as this sociopathic character, and they ask why the family wouldn’t be more horrified. But you have to realize that those characters are looking up from that hole and they’re seeing their family. They’re seeing someone they watched grow up for twelve years of his life. So you can’t be that horrified. As a family, you wouldn’t be horrified. As an audience member I can understand that you might be horrified, because you’re seeing a bunch of strangers in crisis. But as a family, if you look up and you see your parent, or the other way around, it’s a completely different relationship. So I think, from the beginning, they’re trying to come to terms with it, just as John is trying to come to terms with it. He also doesn’t realize what he’s done right away, he acted on a certain impulse; he doesn’t even talk to them until the final scene. So there are things that he’s dealing with. But with the family, the way that we dealt with it was that it was something they should always keep in mind: When they’re looking up, the’re seeing their son. It’s very apparent in the mother’s role, a lot of times she looks up and she’s always worried about him, she’s like, “are you ok?” Still, even then, checking on him. So that is what takes the edge off of this horrific act, to me. And then we also discussed with the actors the emotion of the scene. We never wanted to make this sensationalist; this film could have easily become a slasher film, it could have easily become a horror film, and we were never interested in that. So for me, the containment was important. The fact that they’re in this claustrophobic little space, and how they deal with their emotions. Because when they scream, they hear their loudness resonate in this small room. So it’s like, you don’t want to panic in this sort of setting, you almost want to keep calm and just go with things as they are. I did do a lot of research about the psychology of people who had been kept in captivity, and they’re almost always people who had been kept in captivity by other people (not their sons), so it’s a completely different set of rules. But there were generally seven or eight stages of how these people in captivity behave: First they’re looking, they’re in denial, they don’t know what it is, they start getting angry, then they start blaming each other, then they start losing their minds and going crazy… then they fully surrender, eventually, and in the end they inhabit this space and they make it their home in a way. So they fully surrender to it in some cases. Not always, but frequently. We tried to make every scene represent some part of their descent into this. There’s the scene where Michal C. Hall is blaming the mother for something he doesn’t know, so they’re coping with this experience in their own ways, and they’re losing their minds at one point in there. So that was sort of like the tone inside the hole. The rest of the tone within the film we really tried to borrow from a lot of different genres, but we never fully wanted it to be a “genre film,” so we always say that it takes the language from a lot of these genres (thriller, horror, etc.), but doesn’t fully become them. So I think staying in the periphery of all this was important to us, and was always important to us, and I think it was accomplished through a combination of everything: Acting, the way we shot it, the location, the silence, the sound design (which for me is really important, the silence is really important to me), and I think that silence is what the film is about in many ways.