Q&A with Daniel Geller, Dayna Goldfine, Alan Light, and Sharon Robinson

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Hallelujah: Leonard Cohen, A Journey, A Song

Can you discuss the archival material you have in this film? It’s incredibly comprehensive. 
Daniel Geller: One of the things, I think, that came later in the process — as we began to develop a relationship with Robert Cory, who was Leonard’s manager, and who got him back up and running when all that money was ripped off, and then helped him get on the road, and is also a trustee of the family estate — Leonard began to understand what Dayna and I were trying to do with the movie as we showed pieces of it to him in process. As such, he began to open the door to the archives. The Cohen personal archives. Because at first, the remit was, “don’t ask for anything.” They were giving a tacit blessing to the film, but don’t ask for anything. One of the things, for me, that was a great surprise was that Leonard was using his Polaroid camera to take all these selfies! All along! And they’re beautifully composed… they’re really moody and really interesting. And in some ways, that was just the tip of the iceberg of what he and different people were attempting to do in an age where not everybody had iPhones. The difficulty involved in doing that kind of documentation required real deliberation. Real effort.

He absolutely loved writing

Dayna Goldfine: And Leonard… I mean, I remember calling Sharon about this… one of the joys of finally getting to go into Leonard’s archive, after spending years working with the audio material — would be to find a piece of Leonard’s writing that exemplified what we were listening to. And Sharon had told us about this dialog that she’d had with Leonard when they were in the middle of working on Ten New Songs, and I saw his journal page from that day. And I took a still of it and I sent it to Sharon. And I said, “Sharon… this is the documentation of what you talk about in your show,” and Sharon just said, “yeah… he was a ‘journaler.’ ” He was one of the original “journalers.” And you kind of get a sense of it in the film, when he says that, at age nine when his father died, his urge was to sit down and write what he thinks about as his first liturgical piece of writing. He was just committed to — as he would say — “blackening the page.”

Sharon Robinson: Yes, absolutely. That was his first, and maybe really only, love. He absolutely loved writing. And it was the thing that I saw him doing whenever there was any downtime, whenever there wasn’t anything else going on… he was writing. It was, you know… I guess a calling, for him. I think he knew that he was good at writing, and he knew that he could find the words for almost any human experience or emotion. And he did it all the time.

Dayna Goldfine: And then in terms of the other types of archival… you know, the best skill one can have, I think, is to just be… to have ears that are just constantly hearing all these different things that you don’t even know you’re taking in. For instance, with [Larry] “Ratso” [Sloman], who had that incredible font of cassette recordings, starting with his very first telephone conversation with Leonard… we were in the middle of wrapping up an interview with him, early on. I was wrapping up my sound equipment, and he said — just sort of out of the corner of his mouth — he’s like, “you know… I think somewhere in my house I’ve got all my cassette tapes with all my Leonard conversations.” And it just… I stopped everything and said, “what? Can you repeat that?!” And then it took about two and a half years, but literally every few months I would send a note to Ratso, and I would say, “hey Ratso, have you gone through that closet yet?” And he’d always say no. And then, a couple of years later — on my birthday! — I got a note on Facebook, saying, “Dayna Goldfine, I’ve got a gift for you.” So a lot of it is pestering people! It’s listening to hear someone say something like that… and then following through, not taking ‘no’ for an answer… and not letting someone convince you that their closet is too jumbled up to dig through.

What impact did working on this film have on you, in terms of your understanding and relationship to Leonard Cohen?.

Sharon Robinson: I think Leonard saw religion as a necessary part of life, but that… most religions sort of lead to the same place. And that in many ways, there wasn’t… or there isn’t, rather, ultimately in different religions. And he respected all religions— he used to tell me, “you know, the word ‘Islam’ means peace.” And he had representations of all the great religions (as he called them) in his home. And he was a scholar of all the religions. Even though he was inherently and deeply Jewish himself, he respected the world’s religions.

Alan Light: I feel like I started all of this with a funny relationship to Leonard, because my father and Leonard were classmates at McGill! Same year… my dad was two months older than Leonard to the day. And so, you know, I grew up with Leonard’s college yearbook on the shelf at home! So any time it was, like, the dark brooding Leonard… I’d be like, “oh, come on man— I know what you guys are like!” So it was always a little bit of, like, “Ok… that’s some guy, a lot like my Dad,” you know? And I think what’s been so much fun watching, and being involved in helping with this film (which is a different project than the book I wrote; I really honed in on only the song “Hallelujah” itself, it was intentionally not a deep-dive into his person, it was about one song), I did a short version of what is really explored much more deeply in the film in terms of what in his life leads to this song. Act three in the film is sort of what the heart of the book project was, which was interesting to watch on screen

Q&A with Stefan Forbes

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Hold Your Fire.

The film took place in my old neighborhood—I lived a block and a half from where those events took place, right on the J line. It’s a major intersection, a very busy hub.  To me, this is story of survival, full of miracles. Tell us about developing the film.  

Stefan Forbes: Yeah, this central space in Brooklyn where this all happened was described to me by the cops as, this wasn’t Broadway with the big lights and the stars, this was the Broadway with the dead rats and the dirty needles. I originally thought, that’s dramatic, what an epic framing for my film. When I started making this film, I went there with my friend of twenty years, Fab 5 Freddy, and he was like, this was where we did our shopping, this was our community, I got my Boy Scout uniform in that store. There were storeowners holding on against the urban blight of the 70s and it was a place where everyone congregated. That started inoculating me against these other narratives to the story. When I first discovered the story, I thought, it’s The French Connection, it’s Dog Day Afternoon, it’s Serpico, all these gritty movies that I loved from the 70s, but I wondered, can we tell this in the manner of the 2020s? Can we make other voices heard and listen to everybody? We pay a lot of lip service to pluralism in this society so I thought, yeah, that’ll be easy! But when you actually try to construct a narrative, it’s incredibly challenging. The story was so long and people kept contradicting each other so much. I couldn’t help but feel, well what did happen? We had to do so much work and show so many cuts and really labor in the edit to create balance between these different voices and really welcome people in and to somehow find a way in the filmic space for these stories to co-exist, and for people to talk cinematically in a way they don’t normally do in real life. In Harvey’s [Schlossberg] book, we got a cop point of view, and it was terrific, but I knew I had to go even deeper and talk to all the people involved. I was going up to Attica to interview Dawud [Rahman] and I had thought that Shu’aib Raheem was dead. There was a lot of legwork to put together these conflicting perspectives.

Would we believe Shu’aib if there weren’t a white guy backing up his story?

Jerry Riccio contradicted himself at times … the things he said he would do, what he was aiming to do, what he actually did and how he looks back on it now really speaks to the complexity of human beings. How confident were you in his recollection? It’s all about “the way we saw it,” regardless of what actually happened.

SF: I was leery of Jerry’s point of view and had only seen him in the press as someone who had detested the gunmen and wanted them locked up forever. I was shocked when I started talking to him that he didn’t carry a lot of rancor towards them. One of the moments that everyone comments on is when Jerry learns that Dawud had been in prison for forty-seven years. He’s shocked and responds with empathy. And I wondered, why did I get such a wrong picture of him? One of the things I learned was that victim impact statements are completely stage-managed by the police union. What you see in the paper is planted by the PBA and they make sure that everything is basically a PSA for punitive criminal justice rather than restorative, and rather than victim-centered. They don’t care what victims want; they believe in punishment and they believe in this dominant patriarchal hierarchical masculine model of punishment and violence from policing through criminal justice. It’s not what communities want and it’s making our whole country less safe while not holding perpetrators of violence accountable in any way. Jerry was fascinating to me on many levels, but also, I was shocked at how much he critiqued the police. He said, “they told you they were shooting high, but that was a lie.” Again and again he contradicted the official version of the story. I was amazed because I knew that Shu’aib, as a man of color, his word needed to be verified by someone else. And here’s a hostage who you think would be his enemy, but you’re seeing him support Shu’aib’s point of view—Riccio is co-signing what the Black guy is saying against the cops, who are supposed to be the white guy’s ally. When we talk about race in this country, we often just do it on the surface, especially for white people. We know how to be sort of crafty, and avoid it while putting a black square in our Twitter, and we use a couple bits of lingo like “allyship” and then get away from this conversation as fast as we can because it’s not a safe place for us and we worry we can only do wrong. I really believe in messy conversations, in engaging people a little deeper, where they can’t just put a label on something and they need to search their soul about race and masculinity and who we believe. Would we believe Shu’aib if there weren’t a white guy backing up his story? I’m trying to get into some more nuanced and messy stuff with all of my interviews.

A lot of people have discomfort with this film because there aren’t easy answers. I’m asking the viewer to put a lens of empathy on it and to see that some of the people causing this violence epidemic in our society come from unexpected places. Research shows that the way they police can be a driver of violence. We need to look past this good guy/bad guy rhetoric that the cops themselves love. They love calling people bad guys. A lot of times the progressives call the cops bad guys and see them as evil without acknowledging that officers of many races and cultures are working for change and don’t have a voice in this authoritarian top-down institution. We need to look at people as individuals, and hold them accountable as individuals. Many cops are driven by trauma, and they say in the film, “first you grieve, then you want to go shoot someone.” This is cops in their own words and I thought it was very important to show their emotional wounding so we can begin to unpack some of what’s gone so wrong in America.

Was there any reluctance on the part of Shu’aib to participate in this film?

SF: I didn’t even ask to film him until we had known each other a while. We would go out and talk and I’d hear stories. At one point he turns to me and asks, “when are you going to start interviewing me?” I asked him if he wanted to me and he said, “I’m not getting any younger. I’ve been waiting forty-seven years to tell my side of the story. Let’s start.” He had seen some of my other work and wanted to get into it. My goal is to really let people talk, let them speak and engage in dialogues we’re not really having in America. He watched my last film, Boogie Man, and he said “I see how you let these conservatives talk, and you create a dialogue between them and people on the left that isn’t happening in society.” That’s what I’m trying to do. We’re not having these conversations. I see the film as a conversation between these warring elements that can break up the established head-butting we do in the media and add some nuance and really let people talk. Shu’aib was really interested in being in part of that.

THE NATIONAL BOARD OF REVIEW TO HOST AWARDS GALA TUESDAY, JANUARY 10, 2023 in New York City

New York, NY (June 1, 2022) – The National Board of Review announced today that they will host their annual Awards Gala on Tuesday, January 10, 2023 in New York City.

The National Board of Review’s awards celebrate excellence in filmmaking with categories that include Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor and Actress, Best Supporting Actor and Actress, Best Original and Adapted Screenplay, Best Foreign Language Film, Best Animated Feature, Best Documentary, Breakthrough Performance, and Directorial Debut as well as signature honors such as the Spotlight Award, Freedom of Expression, the William K. Everson Film History Award and the NBR Icon Award.

Additional details about the event will be announced at a later date.

ABOUT THE NATIONAL BOARD OF REVIEW
Since 1909, the National Board of Review has dedicated its efforts to the support of cinema as both art and entertainment. Each year this select group of film enthusiasts, filmmakers, professionals and academics view over 250 films and participates in illuminating discussions with directors, actors, producers and screenwriters before announcing their selections for the best work of the year.  Since first citing year-end cinematic achievements in 1929, NBR has recognized a vast selection of outstanding studio, independent, foreign-language, animated and documentary films, often propelling recipients such as Peter Farrelly’s Green Book and George Miller’s Mad Max: Fury Road into the larger awards conversation. NBR also stands out as the only film organization that bestows a film history award in honor of former member and film historian William K. Everson. In addition, one of the organization’s core values is identifying new talent and nurturing young filmmakers by awarding promising talent with ‘Directorial Debut’ and ‘Breakthrough Actor’ awards as well as grants to rising film students and by facilitating community outreach through the support of organizations such as The Ghetto Film School, Reel Works Teen Filmmaking, and Educational Video Center. With its continued efforts to assist up-and-coming artists in completing and presenting their work, NBR honors its commitment to not just identifying the best that current cinema has to offer, but also ensuring the quality of films for future generations to come.

Join the conversation @NBRfilm

# # #

Press Contacts:  SLATE PR 
Shawn Purdy / Lindsey Brown  
(212) 235-6813
shawn@slate-pr.com / lindsey@slate-pr.com

Q&A with Frank Marshall

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Jazz Fest: A New Orleans Story.

How did this film get underway, and how did you decide to co-direct it?

Frank Marshall: One of the things that happens — as you get older — is that your friends also become experienced, and rise in their careers. And one of my best friends is Jimmy Buffett. It’s great when your heroes become your friends. I like to go on the road and hang out with Jimmy. Back in 2018, we were in Denver and he was playing with the Eagles. And there was a party afterwards. And at the party, there was this gentleman named Quint Davis. I started talking to Quint, and he was a very lively and knowledgeable music fan. And it turns out he’s the co-founder of Jazz Fest! And he said, “can I pick your brain for a second?” And he told me about the impending celebration of the 50th anniversary of Jazz Fest. Fifty years! And I thought that was pretty amazing— I’d never been myself, but of course I’d heard about it. And he said that they really wanted to do something special. He either wanted to shoot a documentary, or do a series, or just cover it somehow. And I said, “I’m in! Let me do it.” And so that’s kind of how it all started.

you’re going to find things that the computer isn’t going to put in your feed

There are so many incredible moments, it’s hard to pick just one to talk about. But the scene with the Marsalis family is really special. How did you arrange that?

FM: The real key, for us, was to have Quint Davis guiding us on who we should talk to. Because there was no way we could talk to — much less actually shoot — everybody. And, you know, it took two of us to direct it, [co-director] Ryan Suffern and myself, and we would split the duties: One of us would be interviewing in one place while the other was out covering a show, or a tent. And to get the Marsalis family together and to be able to talk to each of them was truly special, and something I’ll always remember. And to be able to honor them in that way, and to show the family playing together… I just love the son’s recollections of playing with Dad, and, you know, some musicians even scaring them. So it was very honest, I thought. 

The film is structured so carefully. Can you discuss the editing process?

FM: The city of New Orleans really was the glue, and was a character in the movie. And so, I would use that to have a transition between the different styles of music, the different genres of music, the different foods, the different arts and crafts that are there… so, really, New Orleans is weaved through the entire movie. And I have to mention our editor, Martin Singer. He did a brilliant job. Because it has to have— editing has to have a certain rhythm. So you’re with the music, and then every once in a while you get a sound bite from somebody, but you don’t destroy the feeling of the music you’re listening to. So it doesn’t take away from it, it adds to it. Martin was incredibly important to us for that reason. There were so many times when I wished we could just let the scene play! But we had to find that balance: where do you bring in jazz? Where do you bring in gospel? What leads one thing to another? The other thing I was going to say about Jimmy Buffett: In the end-credits there’s a special reason that he’s singing The Stones “You Can’t Always Get What you Want.” And that’s because The Stones were scheduled to close Jazz Fest that year, and Mick Jagger had a throat problem, and they had to cancel. So Jimmy came in to do the closing in honor of The Rolling Stones. So there’s a little inside info for you there!

What are some of the things you remember most, from the production?

FM: Obviously, when you’re there and you’re looking out from backstage and there are 50,000 people being totally connected to the music that’s going on… you realize it really is a universal language. And just being there, amongst that, and being able to enjoy that… is special. But for me, I also really enjoyed doing some of the interviews. And when you’re talking to the artists about what’s special about Jazz Fest for them, and to hear the history, and to hear about why they’re at Jazz Fest… I thought that Boyfriend had my favorite quote. She said, “you know, you’re going to walk around Jazz Fest and you’re going to find things that the computer isn’t going to put in your feed.” And that’s a line that somebody wouldn’t have said ten years ago.

Q&A with Craig Roberts and Simon Farnaby

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of The Phantom of the Open.

Simon, this is an incredible true story. How did you come to write the script?

Simon Farnaby: I was brought up around golf. My father was a greenskeeper at a little club in northeast England. Golf’s a game I love, but I came at it like Maurice [Flitcroft], from a lower-class angle. The greenskeepers were the great unwashed. You were supposed to stay in the shed and not venture out onto the course. When the juniors at our club heard about Maurice, he became a folk hero. If you were a junior, or in fact a woman, you only had a small amount of time to tee off, and you were looked down upon by all the men. So, he was a huge folk hero for us all, but then I kind of forgot about him. And then I eventually realized I wasn’t good enough at golf to be a professional, unlike Maurice. I got into comedy, I got into making films, and then Maurice died in 2007 and I read the obituary in the newspaper and was reminded, oh, that guy! I hadn’t heard of him between those two periods, so I immediately did a bit of research and wrote a very bad screenplay based on very few facts. Then I thought, I’d better look into this more, so I did loads of research and teamed up with a journalist and met the family, including the twins, who are featured in the film. And the big moment came when I asked if they had any letters or postcards, any written material of their dad’s that might have given insight into his mind. And they initially they said, no, we don’t, and they offered me a drink and then about two hours later, they said, “actually we do! We’ve got his autobiography.” And they bring out from under the bed this 500-page hand-written autobiography that Maurice wrote but was never published. That was just a gold mine. It brought tears to my eyes. Everything he was thinking about, all the stuff that happens in the film, there were lots of things that are straight from the autobiography… the way he took six sugars in his coffee, the speech he gives to his wife at the end, that was glued into the book from when he had written it down in Michigan. The speech to Jean was all verbatim. He kept the letters between him and Keith Mackenzie, every word of their exchanges in the film comes from those letters, and there were more in the book! Until Mackenzie gave up corresponding. So then I wrote a better screenplay, and got an amazing director who shared my vision. He wanted it to be colorful and fun and not too kitchen-sinky, and here we are.

it’s about someone really wanting to do something in a world that tells them they can’t

Craig, how did you come to the film and what aspect of the story drew you in?

Craig Roberts: I loved Simon’s script. I had made two films before this that I had written myself, and I suppose I had this pretentious idea that I would be an auteur that would only direct his own scripts. But when I read Simon’s script, I loved it and wished I had written it myself. Sally Hawkins had played a paranoid-schizophrenic in my second film, Eternal Beauty. And much like in that film, the whole way we framed this movie was to take someone’s perceived weakness and turn it into a strength. It was a comedy, and I suppose you’re not laughing at her, you’re laughing with her, when she’s making jokes. I think that helped me understand Maurice’s story, and that’s what Simon and the producers saw in me. I pitched for it, I begged to do it, and I got it. And there were a few things that drew me in. When you’re telling a story about a real person, most of the time people know that real person, so there’s an expectation. That was fun to explore. And it’s a class story and a birth lottery story, but it’s about someone really wanting to do something in a world that tells them they can’t, and that’s what I really loved about it. It had so much heart.

The cast is phenomenal. Did you encounter any challenges during the casting process?

CR: There were no challenges in casting this film. People are really fans of Simon’s work, so that helped when sending the script. We wanted Mark Rylance because we didn’t want a comedic actor in it, we wanted a character actor that was grounded and would make it real, one who would lean into the drama. The script was very funny anyway. We sent it Mark because we thought we should try for the very best. And he’d actually never been sent a comedy before. The timing was quite good. We both know Sally Hawkins quite well, and she’s amazing. She’s really the heart of this film and the support system. The hardest thing was actually finding the twins. We were worried that we wouldn’t find the right energy, but we did some self-tapes and I when I was shown their tape [Christian and Jonah Lees], I was blown away by how much life they had. In another world, they’d probably be in the movie even more because they’re just so fun.

SF: They weren’t very good dancers though, were they?

CR: No, they were terrible! That was something they had to learn.

Simon, how did your part in the film as the French golfer come about?

SF:  Well, we needed someone who could swing a golf club. And luckily for me, there aren’t many professional golfers that are also good actors. I was forced into it, really! Jim Howard, who you see in the film, was the first Black PGA player and actually played with Maurice that day. He was so happy to be involved in the film and loved his day with Maurice. But there was another player that hated Maurice that didn’t want anything to do with the film, so I stepped in to fill his role as the one who thought Maurice was wasting everyone’s time. And it was a great excuse to dress up like one of the 1970s golfers.

Can you talk a bit collaborating with some of your crew members?

CR: It’s my favorite part of the process, really, the collaboration. When you’re making a movie—David Lynch says this—you have an idea, and when you collaborate, people put their ideas on top of your idea. I’ve worked with the same costumer designer for my past three movies now [Sian Jenkins], and interestingly the design all comes from a very weird reference… it’s Superman. When I read Simon’s script, there’s a moment where he opens his overalls, like Superman. One of my favorite movies is Punch Drunk Love by Paul Thomas Anderson, where Adam Sandler has social anxiety but it’s framed in a way that he’s an alien and he’s Superman, so I took inspiration from that. That informed the whole design of the movie. His golf attire is all diamond shapes in the colors of Superman. The hat is kind of like his cape. The dog is the same dog that Superman had, and at the beginning you see a shooting star coming down, like Superman. Because Maurice has his own superpower, and it’s his confidence in himself.

My DP was Kit Fraser. We shot on 35mm, and then on 16mm for the golf scenes. I really like to preview most of the things we’re going to shoot. I’m sure if we were improvising the whole thing, it would be a lot more expensive. We wanted a 70s feel, so we referenced Boogie Nights, the King of Comedy a little bit, all the flashing cameras and the freeze frames. In terms of music, Isobel Waller-Bridge did the score. There’s a soap in the UK called Coronation Street, and that was the choice as a reference for the score. It was a bit of a strange choice, but I grew up with it, and it felt nostalgic and romantic.