Q&A with Edward Berger

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of All Quiet on the Western Front.

It’s an incredible piece of filmmaking. How did you come up with a shot list?

Edward Berger: I spent months and months and months with the DP, James Friend, who is a friend of mine.  We’ve known each other since Patrick Melrose. During prep, I spent more time with him than with my family, unfortunately. We locked ourselves in a room for three months in Berlin, and we’d do 10-14 day stretches at a time. Meticulous is the right word. We were obsessed with finding the right shots to tell the story. The movie didn’t have much money—compared to American films, laughable—so we really needed to plan and know exactly what we were going to do. And we spent those months storyboarding everything, especially the battle scenes, completely. If you were to put the storyboards next to the movie, it would look exactly the same. Maybe a shot was dropped, or two were swapped, but it’s really what we conceived. It’s the part of planning I really enjoy. I would also say that in a film like this, very often you might use two, three, four, five cameras to capture everything and make sure you have the coverage. We shot everything single camera. There was a second camera there that we would use to plan ahead, but 99.5% of the time, we shot with just one camera to get exactly the precise moment that we felt would let the audience experience what Paul was feeling. That was the main motivation, to give the audience the feeling of what Paul has in his stomach.

Everything is there to put you in Paul’s shoes.

Your DP said that his collaboration with you is one of the most unique he’s had with a director.  

EB: We’re both obsessed with precision and architecture in the film. It’s not haphazard and we don’t try to find the shot on set. It gives me true pleasure to set up a shot and in that shot, have every department create the illusion that this is reality. Let it be production design, the SFX, makeup, the smoke that’s in the background or the explosion that is nearby, the wear and tear on the costumes, the music… everything is there to make that moment feel real. Everything is there to put you in Paul’s shoes. We both really love the crafting of each shot.

I heard that during the battle sequences you put a whiteboard with the storyboards next to the camera. That’s a technique I’ve really only experienced in commercial work. Can you talk about that?

EB: With commercials, they are making short stories but they have more time, and it’s for the client. For us, it was more a means to keep our sanity. On any movie, I think you have to think about the whole film. This shot will pay off there later, etc. But on the battle scenes, if I had to think about the whole film, it would have broken me. I really needed to break those down into little bits by really planning those scenes of the movie ahead of time, in our hotel room with storyboards. This shot will flow into the next, here’s what we need here, and so on. You really imagine the film again and again on the wall in a stark hotel room. We kind of planned the whole film and had hundreds of hours of discussions with the departments so that they knew what we needed to achieve on any given day. And on the day when James and I drove to set, sometimes in the morning I’d almost be in tears thinking about how we’d never get it done, and he’d prop me up. And the next day he would be down and I’d try to prop him up. We also didn’t have much leeway. If we didn’t finish a certain scene, there was no way to pick it up the next day. There was no time. We’d get to set and say, let’s just do one shot at a time. That really helped mentally, one a shot at a time. It’s very gratifying, and gives you joy and relief. Then you go to the next shot, and at the end of the day you realize we did these seven shots or these twenty-two shots and we accomplished what we wanted! It was like a mental crutch.

I can’t believe this was your lead’s first movie role—he was phenomenal. Did that change the way you approached your process at all?

EB: Felix Kammerer’s headshot was the first one I received, from [producer] Malte Grunert’s wife. She said, you should look at this kid, he’s in Vienna in the Burgtheater— the most preeminent theater in Europe. She told me he had mostly small parts and had just finished drama school, and he’s never been in front of a camera. Which was kind of great. We had always wanted to discover someone because we wanted the audience to have the feeling that they are discovering someone. If you haven’t seen this person before, you can encounter him with innocence, just like he went with innocence into this war. In a movie like this, you want your lead to be a whiteboard that the audience can project onto, not a familiar face. He came to about four or five casting sessions, and in the second one I put him in a uniform and heavy boots. He’s not a solider, and that was helpful. He’s an intelligent kid who went to a good school; he’s a dancer and light in his movements. Putting those heavy boots on him really grounded him. When you wear different shoes, you walk differently. That’s what happened to Felix and he grew into this role. I also think he has sort of an old-fashioned face. He could be from any era. You looked at him and he looked like he could have lived a hundred years ago. All of the young actors, in the makeup and costume tests, they were all so excited about the shoot. For many of them it was the biggest film they had done and they were so excited to start this adventure. Looking at them, it rang true. These kids were away from home for first time, and their grandfathers had been heroes from previous wars that had been won very quickly. They were really told that in three weeks they’d be in Paris and it would be over and they’d return heroes. They didn’t have TV back then so they didn’t know what it was really like. They were exposed to propaganda and populist speech and were manipulated.

How did you come to find that searing three-note musical score?

EB: Volker Bertelmann [the composer] and I are very good friends. We’ve done three or four movies together. I showed him the film and said three things. First of all, I wanted the music to sound like something we’ve never had before, to be different. Because to me that puts the movie in a different realm. In some movies, you want the music to disappear, but in this movie, I felt we needed to lift it into someplace else. Second, I wanted him to destroy the adventures, to make them dirty and not beautify anything. And the third thing was, again, what does Paul feel in his gut? The fear, the rage, the thirst for blood, the coldness, I wanted him to find a sound for that. I showed him the film and two days later he said, I think I’ve got something. I listened to it and I immediately said, don’t change anything. That became the theme. The nice thing is that is sounds quite modern, and I like that it’s not historically accurate. That drumbeat whips around your ears. A certain note of destruction is what I was looking for. The instrument used is a hundred-year-old instrument that Volker inherited from his grandmother. He refurbished it and it’s called a harmonium. He played these three notes, and in the harmonium you basically puff air with foot pedals. You hear the machine, the creaks and cracks of the harmonium. It’s another theme of the film—the machinery and industrialization of war. Humans becomes killing machines. They lose everything that is warm and human. It fit the theme of the film and then he put it through a distortion app, and that’s how it came about.

Do you think there was something that a German director could say about this story that no one else could?

EB: That’s the only reason why I made it. It’s a German novel and it’s part of our cultural heritage. It really sits deep with me and I read it when I was very young. When my producer called me to ask if we should make this movie together, I went home and thought, what a great idea. It’s been sitting there, but should I really make this? There’s another film that was made that’s probably on the top lists of many filmmakers, so the potential for failure was huge. I went home and discussed it at the dinner table, and my kids are usually not interested in my work. But the moment I mentioned the title, my daughter whipped around and said, I just read it in school—she was seventeen at the time—and you have to make it, it’s the best book I’ve ever read. So if a girl of age seventeen, ninety years later is still impacted by the book, it must have some relevance today. I made the movie because in America, in England, you can look back at the scars from the wars as much as in any other county. But there’s also a sense of pride. Americans can tell a hero’s journey because their fathers went to help liberate Europe from Fascism. The English defended their country because they were attacked. There’s something honorable there. There is a sense of legacy and pride you can look back on. In Germany, there’s nothing but shame, guilt, horror, terror, a sense of responsibility towards what happened. I grew up with that and still feel it, even generations later. It’s in my DNA. I thought if I made a film, creatively, I’d have something new to add the conversation. And it might be interesting for other countries to see how Germans tell their story, with that history.

Q&A with Chris Smith

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Sr.

Is it correct that you had a very small crew, during production? Was that always the plan?
Chris Smith: When we first went out to Robert Downey Jr.’s house in the Hamptons, he said that we couldn’t bring a crew. Which I only found out two days beforehand. And I personally had not picked up a camera in almost ten years. I had shot my first five movies, but as the business evolved… and people were using cinematographers, it was just sort of something that I wasn’t doing any more. So this actually got me back shooting, which was a great, liberating thing for me. On Hundred Foot Wave, I went over with, you know, just a C300, and I had a sound kit and a light… I think, generally, the production values of documentaries has changed so much in recent years: people are shooting with Alexas, and it’s really fancy. This film was just me, and Kevin [Ford] shooting, and maybe sound once in a while…. but it was very low-fi. That kind of got me excited about this kind of opportunity with documentary, which is so liberating, and which feels so real… and is how I started thirty years ago!

This film changed my life, and the way that I make movies, completely.

“Follow the film” is a filmmaking ethos that we learn about in your movie. Can you discuss what that concept means to you?
CS: There are two things I should say about that: during our very first interview, we were going through Robert Downey Sr.’s filmography, and he talked about Rittenhouse Square, which was a documentary he did — the last film that he did — and he said that they learned early on to “trust anything, and anything can happen.” And I thought that was such a guiding force for this project. Like, it was something that… you realized, that if you open yourself up to… I mean, I’ve always looked at documentaries as, the best that we can do [as documentarians] is to reflect back the world that we’ve been allowed into. And the experience of making this film definitely challenged that! I thought it was an interesting challenge to try to do. This film changed my life, and the way that I make movies, completely. You know… I’m someone who has a little bit of OCD, so I’m always trying to control everything in film, because… you know, if the sun is moving, you’re worried about the lighting, for instance. In the past I might have said, “we can’t shoot here— the conditions aren’t perfect.” And one thing that Sr. imparted on us… for example, when we were interviewing him in that theater and a siren goes off, and you hear me say, “wait, we’ve got to hold up for the siren,” he just says, “oh, it’s fine! It all fits.” And, to me, it made me think about the world around us differently. We did a series on big wave surfing, called Hundred Foot Wave, which I shot right after this, and the main interview happened during a hail storm. So it went from cloudy, to bright sun, back to cloudy, back to bright sun… and hail was hitting the windows… and the pipes started banging… and normally, I would have gotten in my own head, and frustrated, and decided to cancel the interview— we’ve just got to do it at a different time. But coming off of Sr., I learned to sort of accept the chaos of the things we can’t control. And that, to me, was probably the best thing to come out of this experience.

With this film, you’ve likely introduced many people to Robert Downey Sr.’s films. Was it a challenge to incorporate his work into your own?
CS: I think one of the main missteps we made, when we first started working on the movie, is that we actually tried to make it a retrospective of his career. And that is where we failed, I think. In the final cut, there’s enough in there that, if you’re interested, you can go back and you can watch those films. But it was… we were sort of being lead by the work, as opposed to actually being lead by his life, and his relationship with Jr. So that was something that took a while to figure out. Because when we started, he also wasn’t ill, you know? The first day we shot, we went out to lunch and walked somewhere. So I never looked at it as, “we’re going to be documenting the decline of someone’s life.” He seemed like he had a lot of energy, and a lot of opinions! So I just thought it would be great— an interesting portrait of this person. So I think, in my head, when we started… it was just looking at the life of an artist. And then it evolved. But those things that you start with can stay with you, and can kind of become almost like an obstacle— and that was something that took a while to let go of, and to realize that, no, we don’t have to do an exhaustive retelling of his career: if people want to learn more about his movies, they can do that. I don’t think that’s the role of— that’s an element of this film, but it’s not the primary focus.

Throughout your career, you’ve followed many kinds of subjects and told many kinds of stories. But it seems like ‘portrait of an artist’ stories hold a special place for you, given that your first film American Movie, has some similar themes to Sr.
CS: American Movie was interesting in the sense that [the subject of the film and I] were living almost the exact same life at that time: I was living in the edit room when he was down there editing… They told me I could use their facilities, so I was sleeping behind the flatbeds. It was interesting because, like, a lot of it was just me and a camera… and the situation was mirrored in that what was happening to him was also happening to me. I had a film at Sundance, and anyone I told I was making American Movie as the next film told me it was a terrible idea. And I don’t disagree with their criticism! Because making a movie about making a movie is not usually a good idea. But I just felt like… I had a conviction that maybe there was something there. But in terms of why you’re drawn to certain things… the only thing I can go off of, is that it’s an instinct. Just sometimes, certain things seem interesting to you, at whatever point in your life you’re at. And in this case, meeting Robert Downey Sr… he was just an interesting person to spend time with. And I felt like if I enjoyed that experience, I would hope it would transfer to other people.

Q&A with Laura Poitras

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of All the Beauty and the Bloodshed.

You really weave so many stories together so beautifully in the film. How did you and Nan weave in and out of each other’s lives?

Laura Poitras: Nan and I have intersected, sometimes literally or sometimes we’ve come across each other’s work. I was first introduced to Nan’s artwork when I was studying filmmaking at the San Francisco Art Institute. That was the late 80s and she had already published the book version of The Ballad of Sexual Dependency, which I think is how the larger audience came to know her work, those that weren’t in New York. But she was also still traveling with the slideshow and she would come to the Bay Area to screen. I never got to see it with her projecting, but I did see Ballad in the early 90s. She was always a groundbreaking woman and artist who was just creating a new cinematic language. I find her still photographs to be so cinematic, right? They suggest stories that you lean into with the framing and the mise en scene. And then obviously the sequencing creates a storytelling in the slideshows. When I made Citizen Four and was traveling with it, we met at a film festival and then we reconnected around the Sackler issue and pain. We were working on a letter—there had been another situation of toxic philanthropy in the art world and a mutual friend invited both Nan and I for breakfast. It was during that breakfast that she told me about the film because Nan had already begun filming her actions with the intention of making a film. During this meeting she said she was looking for collaborators. She was also was looking for producers and we started talking about Howard Gertler, who she had just met and who was one the producers on How to Survive a Plague, about the AIDS crisis. I kept thinking about the project and volunteered for it after that.

I was struck by your background and her background and the two of you doing this together. There must have been a point where you had this conversation about how this was going to work.

LP: With non-fiction filmmaking, there is always something of an organic process that happens. You go in with a set of ideas and then they evolve and change. I was originally very compelled by the contemporary story of Nan taking on the Sackler family and these protests and the sort of direct action that felt very in line with my previous works. I was a little nervous about the artist biography part just because there are so many films about renowned people and I wonder how they function as stories… do they rely on the renown of the subject versus standing alone as films? So I had a little hesitancy there, but I couldn’t not do it. I couldn’t not go into her or go into her work. It was a very specific thing that happened. I was working on the film and saw her piece about her sister which is called Sisters, Saints and Sibyls. There’s a short excerpt where you see the three screens. It’s a devastating work about her sister. And there are certain lines in that, after her sister’s suicide and after her mother says to tell the children it was an accident. It sort of felt so much about what drives Nan. Like this relentless pursuit of truth. This idea of pretending it was an accident, I think that catapulted her at a very young age into being someone who is in resistance to what mainstream society is thinking. That’s what her family was thinking, or what the 50s and 60s thought of young girls and sexuality. I think at a very young age Nan was thrust into oppositional positions. When I saw this piece, I felt like it was so important that the film include her sister. But I didn’t know if that was something that Nan wanted. I would have obviously respected if she didn’t want to talk about something so deep and so painful. We talked and I told her why I thought it was important to the film, and she said that it was something she would talk about in the film. And we worked very closely on how the story of her sister is told in the film.

There’s something so fierce about Nan and she’s been on the right side of history for so long

Were there other specific parts of this film that you felt strongly about including in the film that you two had discussions about?

LP: Going back to the theme of portrait versus biopic, I was very clear that I wanted not to make a film that was, this happened, then this happened, and that was just following the beats of her life. I wanted to be selective around the story we were telling and particularly that it’s casting a critique on the larger society. This is the cruelty of society—of this society, not all societies. With the editing team, we first had Joe Bini who is a really incredible editor and who had worked with Werner Herzog and Lynne Ramsay, among others. He worked on this document by going through the material and built this dramaturgy document which had this kind of weaving and these themes. And each of these chapters had a theme. The first theme was “Merciless Logic,” which is a kind of like, this is who we are as a society. This is a society that destroys people, a society that crushes people that rebel, it’s a society that is conservative and allows the Sackler family to profit off many generations of Americans dying. And the government says nothing. I knew very early on that it was going to move in the direction of cinematic societal critique. And I knew very early on that the exhibition she did in New York at Artists Space was going to be a pinnacle of the film, at the beginning of third act. It was something so important that Nan twice stopped herself in that situation and was looking around and saying, generations are dying, my generation is dying here. And the government is doing nothing; people are doing nothing. I knew there would be a convergence between the contemporary pain thread and what happened around the AIDS crisis and particularly this exhibition, which was an unapologetic celebration of queer sexuality, while also acknowledging the devastation of this community. It’s kind of hard to imagine all that Nan endured. Someone who found her family and David Armstrong in the work she did and the trans communities in Boston and New York and then lost so many of those close friends. I knew I was always going to have include that, from early on. Then who to focus on kind of emerged from that. There’s a lot of people in Nan’s life that aren’t featured in the film because we had to make certain choices. David Armstrong was clearly important, Cookie Mueller, David Wojnarowicz… what a man. If only we had his voice today.

Well in a way we do, because of his art. Can you talk about the interviews and over what period of time they took place? I was very moved when we were allowed to hear Nan say “could you please stop,” and I wonder if there were other moments like that.

LP: We wanted the audience to feel that something was happening over time and the interviews didn’t just happen in an afternoon. And that there was a back and forth. They took place probably over a year and half. They were audio only in Nan’s apartment in the same room where the meetings would happen, in the living room. I would come over and I sort of joke we’d procrastinate for a few hours because it was not easy stuff to get into. We were specific in each of them about what we would talk about, so she knew ahead of time. Sometimes someone else would be there. When we talked about Barbara [her sister] it was important for both of us to make sure someone else was there to make sure we were okay in how we processed it before and after. That was her close colleague, Alex Kwartler, who is an executive producer on the film and was very involved by working with her and making sure it was safe, because it was really intense stuff that she shares in this film. So we did these over a year and half, we did the first round and made a rough cut, we showed it to Nan, and then there were things she wanted to back and talk about more.

Were there things you thought you knew about Nan and her work where you realized, I didn’t really know this at all?

LP: In the second chapter called “Another Realm,” I hadn’t realized she was so young when she was sent to foster care and was kind of on her own at such a young age. And then this whole body of work that MIT gave with the polaroid cameras. That story I didn’t know the extent of—the fact that she still had these photographs, and that they feel like the work of a mature artist. Those David Armstrong photographs are so beautiful and she was such a young person making them, yet she was so fully formed as an artist. That was an incredible discovery. There was one of her first pictures of David and Tommy in the sand pit, and we had that photograph from far away, and late in the editing process she found the close-up. It was just these two beautiful queer men in a time when being queer, there wasn’t language for it.

Can you talk about the questions that you chose to answer, and the questions that you chose not to answer?

LP: We were not interested in teasing the audience or withholding anything. I think with any film, there’s a time when the audience has the emotional capacity to connect to something. And in the film we’re talking specifically about her sister. There were times when things in the third part were earlier, and we experienced that the audience was not ready. There were certain things we wanted to lay out, and certain things we chose to withhold because we felt like the audience’s emotional capacity had shifted over time. For instance, there’s this very powerful line where Nan says “that’s the problem. How do you show the world that you did experience it, you did feel that, it did happen, that’s why I take pictures.” It’s a very thesis-like statement. We tried that once earlier in the film, and it just felt like random exposition. A thesis statement, but not in a good way. But hopefully when you hear it at the end, it’s with emotion and says something about not only her sister, but why she does what she does as an artist. That’s just storytelling. You try things, maybe this doesn’t work here but it’s important and we’ll come back to it. I did think that this film takes you on a journey or down rabbit holes and you don’t know why you’re going down it, and then you learn later. For instance, some people know some of the characters like Cookie, but some people don’t, they don’t know she was such a force, and we don’t want to manipulate that.

What has been interesting for you as you’ve traveled with this film?

LP: I think the thing that’s been moving is how this film emotionally resonates with people, and sometimes in very different ways. Sometimes people have experience with addiction or they have a sibling that they’ve lost, or coming out. It’s powerful to see the different ways it resonates and that’s what we wanted. In the editing, we really wanted it to stay with people and move them in some way. When you direct non-fiction, you’re having your own experiences, and you hope that the audience has some of those as well. There’s something so fierce about Nan and she’s been on the right side of history for so long. She had to makes these choices at a very young age, and they’re not easy choices.

Q&A with Sarah Polley, Jessie Buckley, Claire Foy, Ben Whishaw, Rooney Mara, and Dede Gardner

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Women Talking.

Can you describe your approach to adapting the novel, and to making the story so cinematic?
Sarah Polley: I think I always thought of the story as somewhat of an epic. So I always felt like it had to breathe, and feel expansive, and you had to feel the world they were going to be having this impact on, by having this conversation and thinking about both dismantling the world they were a part of, and building a new one. So it always seemed to me that it needed a scale and a scope and to breathe. 

How do you find your way into characters that have experienced such trauma?
Jessie Buckley: I guess… you’re working with such incredible people, you know? And everybody showed up for everybody every day. And you just have to sink into the stream and see how it affected you. This wasn’t like… it was an experience from something that was kind of being formed and projected, and you’d feel like you were changing throughout the course of a scene.

It just dawned on me that we’ve all got to come to the same conclusion…

Ona is a very centering presence in the film; she’s quite measured in how she reacts. Where do you think that comes from?
Rooney Mara: I think Ona has always been an outsider in that community, and has probably always had a higher level of consciousness, or connectedness, to some sort of spirit. I think she does have a sort of peace to her, but I think it’s also because she has a sort of peace with herself that she probably had to get at a young age because she was different. She has more of an education than the other women… and she has a real love for her community and her faith, in spite of the fact that she’s different. And she’s chosen to live not like the other women, but she still has such a deep connection the community and to her faith. I think she has an extraordinary amount of empathy, and sensitivity, and an ability to remain open. And that’s why she is able to sort of… not mediate, but she’s able to remain open through all of this, through whatever the other person she’s talking with is feeling, without judgement.

The character of August bears such a huge responsibility to these women. Can you talk about discovering the character, and what it was like being the only male in the ensemble?
Ben Whishaw: In the book, there’s loads more information about August. So I had a whole backstory given to me in the book, which is amazing. So it was all there for me, right at the start. It was wonderful being the only male on the set! Yeah, I don’t know: it was just an amazing… very unusual experience. I’m very blessed to have been there, and to watch, and it was beautiful. I had such a beautiful time. I just love this cast. That said, it’s a complicated position August is in. He is a man, after all. I mean, he’s aware of how complex it is for him to be in that room with what’s unfolding in front of him. But, yeah, he’s like Ona: he’s an outsider as well. He doesn’t really fit into that community at all.

RM: He’s a different kind of victim. Like Ona says in the film, they’re all — the men and the women — they’re all victims of the circumstance.

In the book, August is the narrator. Can you discuss the decision to change that, for the film?
SP: In the book, we’re reading August’s minutes of the meeting. And I wrote the script that way, we shot the film that way, we recorded it… and it was a beautiful voiceover. In the book it works beautifully. Ben’s voiceover was beautiful. And then at around the three month mark in editing, we just realized something wasn’t working. And I think it was a realization that the immediacy of sound, the intimacy of it, and of picture (adapting the material into a different medium, essentially), meant that not hearing the story from the voice of one of the women who’d experienced the trauma was distancing. So Dede [Gardner] and Fran [McDormand] had a big conversation. And Dede said, “should we look at the narrator? What if it’s Ona telling this story to her unborn child from the future?” And then Chris Donaldson, our editor, had this beautiful idea: What if it’s Autje? And I always wanted more of Autje! I was always trying to get her more central, just based on Kate Hallett’s performance. I just wanted her there. So Chris said, “what if it’s her, as the youngest person in the room?” And so it became a real experiment. And I kind of went away and wrote for a week: stream-of-consciousness voiceover, and very intentionally did not think of where it would go and how it would work. And then we would kind of choose a section and see what we could construct around that, and how that would feed into the film. But we kind of did this… it felt very reckless! We’re not doing this literally, or in terms of structure… we’re just going to throw the whole film at the wall and break it, and see what we can do as we pull it apart. And it was so exhilarating. You know, Kate was sending little voice memos as temp voiceover tracks, and we would try to construct something… and it was so fun.

JB: I’d love a voice memo from Kate every day! That’d be so nice! 

Dede Gardner: It was one of the best times of my life, when we were figuring this all out. Because you go from terrified (but so in it together… so, so committed and you think, “we’re just not stopping until we’re done, and we’re not done until it’s excellent.”) And we had this… partnership, and trust, with Chris the editor. Every night was fun. Every night they would send me a scene, and it would be cut with something, or the Kate stuff… and what about these lines, where do you put them? And it was just… building something together. I don’t know; it felt miraculous, to be honest.

SP: It was truly exciting. What was great was, we were starting from this point of, “this definitely doesn’t work.” So then anything after that was fun! You can’t be disappointed in that moment. And just to get to sort of collectively find our way closer to closer to the film we always wanted to make was incredible. And, weirdly, I think it feels truer to the book in how it is on screen than how it did when it was more literally done in the script.

DG: It makes you feel the way the book made you feel. So inside those two points, I think the guardrails can be super elastic. But we were making something every night— it was amazing.

JB: I think being on set with those two young women was quite profound. For me, it was quite profound. And knowing that these young women were the catalyst for change, for this story to start. I kept thinking about the dynamic between mother and daughter and actually how the daughter says, “stop looking away! Look at it! Be brave! Have it!” And what’s been so moving is seeing these young women, as women in the world, as young actresses, having had this experience — which is their first ever filming job — and Kate said something which I keep thinking about: “I stepped into this film thinking that I had to be good… and then I realized that there was a lot that was expected of me… and now I know that I can expect a lot.” And, like, as an eighteen year old woman, I’m like, “holy hell!” If this film can have that effect on this person, with this experience, that is the most incredible gift we can give. But I felt that throughout the whole film, I felt that from them, when were doing it.

SP: I think we were always looking for ways to make them more central. I feel like everyone, at some point, came to me and said, “how can I get more scenes with Kate?” And it was very clear, instinctually from the beginning, that Kate was central…. but it just took us a long time to figure out how that worked. 

JB: Well she’s such a silent power in that character; she’s so elemental to this meeting happening. And Kate as a person is quite silently powerful, in a really intense, direct, beautiful, interesting way. And she never let that go, you know? You feel that from her as a young woman.

Did your own conception of your character change, as you went through the process of filming? Was your understanding informed in any way by what your scene partners did?
Claire Foy: I’ll admit that when I read a script… I’m not very good at seeing the arc of the whole story, basically… it’s a failing of mine. I can see my particular character’s journey, but I can’t distance myself from the story. I really struggle with that, for some reason. And so for this film, I didn’t realize until we’d gotten to the point in the film where… it’s when me and Rooney have a moment where I’m like, “you’re changing your mind!” And I realized… “oh fuck. This is what the film’s about!” But I just didn’t really… we had never talked about the ‘Big Ideas’ of the film, we had never talked, necessarily, about the grand scheme of everything; we never talked about it from a wider viewpoint, from a distance. And suddenly… that was very significant, for me, as a character; I realized, “I’m on a slide, now, and it’s getting faster and faster and faster and faster.” I realized everything was different— my character suddenly knew where this was headed. Everyone is looking at me, everyone is wanting me to change my mind. Maybe that’s exactly how it should happen: That it didn’t hit me, what was going on, until it hit the character. It just dawned on me that we’ve all got to come to the same conclusion… and we’ve got to leave.

Q&A with Kristy Guevara-Flanagan and Helen Hood Scheer

The following questions and answers are excerpted from a conversation that followed the NBR screening of Body Parts.

How did you two come to work on this project together?

Kristy Guevara-Flanagan: I made a short film called What Happened to Her a few years ago which was about dead women on screen and our cultural obsession in the media with those images. I interviewed an actress who played the part of a dead body, and I thought there was something interesting about that combination of not only these images, but what goes into the making of them. At that time, Helen approached me and wanted to work together with me on my next project. We started working on what we thought would be a triptych, looking at sex, birth, and death on screen from a women’s perspective. We started the one about sex and it was an avalanche of ideas and people and different actors that we wanted to speak with, and that’s really where it began.

Helen Hood Scheer: By that time Kristy and I were both living in Los Angeles, teaching at UCLA and Cal State Long Beach, where we both run the respective documentary programs. Before we taught in southern California, we taught at a community college together, Northern California, and that’s where we met. We were already professional colleagues and friends when we started making the film

It’s a slow, thoughtful, reflective process

There’s a precision to this film that only academics can bring. How did you cast your net for interview subjects?

KGF: We were not only interested in big celebrities, but also people who worked behind the scenes, people who weren’t your well-known identified celebrities, the working-class actor. This range of perspectives was always going to be an important part of the film. I consider it an ensemble piece.

HHS: From the get-go, having a diverse range of perspectives was really important to us; diverse ages, diverse stages in their careers, diverse types. When we started out, building on Kristy’s initial short, we thought we would record all the interviews with audio only and mix them with images and animation. When Jane Fonda agreed to do the film, we had already done a few audio interviews. And very quickly we said, we can’t record Jane Fonda with audio only. We brought out the cameras and it was at that point that the film began expanding from being a short film focusing on body doubles to being a feature focusing on intimacy and nudity in a much larger perspective. And we thought initially that once we got Jane Fonda, we would have an easy time and the doors would just open for access. That turned out not to be the case. It’s continually really challenging to get through the gatekeepers—the agents, publicists, managers. There were a couple of reasons for that. One was that many celebrities were still very hesitant to have people reconsider early work they did when they might have been less clothed than they are now in their careers. There was a lot of fear and also some fear of retribution. Despite the fact that people were being more open after the Harvey Weinstein scandal broke, we actually started production months before that scandal broke. So we were sort of poised to take advantage of the new energy people had towards sharing their ideas. But the fact of the matter is, many celebrities were still very hesitant to speak. Jane was very courageous, as were many others, but a lot of celebrities turned us down. A lot of lesser-known actors were willing to participate and we found that to be ultimately really fascinating because those are the people that don’t have access to the machinations of power and publicity and the ability to get their voices heard. The celebrities can tell their stories other ways and they do, so we again created an ensemble piece from people from different fields, directors, actors, writers, and all from different stages in their careers. It became an asset to the film, but it was something that evolved from our initial plans once filming began.

Can you talk about your interview process? I was really wowed by Rose McGowan.

KGF: As scholars, we really love research so we did as much research as we could. We read the trades. People like Rose McGowan and Jane Fonda have memoirs, I read all that I could and tried to watch all their work. This film was also made over a number of years, so people were at different stages in terms of going public with things that had happened in the industry. We did have the fortune of interviewing Rose after she had gone public about Harvey Weinstein and people had finally listened to her. She was so brave and it was such a wonderful interview. We always tell our subjects, this is what we want to talk about. We give them the scope of what we’re interested in discussing to make sure that they’re aware we’re going to be asking hard and difficult questions. We’re also aware of what’s already been said publicly. That offers some information about what they might feel comfortable talking about. It’s a slow, thoughtful, reflective process. I do the interviews and give them a lot of space. We have a small set and crew so there’s intimacy. There’s always a pre-interview process where we talk about what we’ll explore. I’m looking for what is emotional and what is going to relate to an audience to help them understand all that goes through an actor’s head, all that they have been put through behind the scenes. Revealing that and unearthing it in a way audiences can understand is key in order to make them sympathetic to the people we’re interviewing.

HHS: As Kristy mentioned, she does pre-interviews, and also her interviews are not short. Each of those interviews was about 90 minutes. There are a lot of questions, a lot of follow-up questions, and she also opens up the questions to me. I’m doing sound on the interviews in order to keep the crew small. Rose was really spectacular because, frankly, we had heard people could be hesitant to interview her. They had said she comes across a certain way that makes her very hard to edit. We went through with the interview and thought she was a dream to work with. Honestly, it seemed like she was responding to our emails directly. She didn’t seem to have assistants around her. She didn’t want makeup, she didn’t want anyone to drive her; she did those things herself. And she was phenomenal. There was so much we weren’t able to include in the film. She was a brilliant speaker and everything we had heard about her felt like it was part of the machine, the abuse she had been through. It felt like she had been typecast in a certain way that was so different than what our experience with her was. She was so smart and articulate and she had been through a lot of public speaking as a result of her book. We might have benefited from that. By the time she did our interview, she had a really strong clear distanced way of explaining some of her ideas in a more intellectual way, and not only in a personal way. She was able to navigate both lenses at the same time.

What is it like to spend so much time listening to women re-experience their trauma?

KGF: It can be emotionally exhausting for many reasons. Documentaries take a really long time to make, so that’s just our own labor outside of the content itself. Then these interviews are intellectually draining because they’re long and detailed and you’re trying to bear witness to people’s experiences. This idea of bearing witness is a guiding one in terms of my approach to documentary filmmaking and what gives it a bigger responsibility that I am beholden to. My gold standard is that I’m bearing witness to people that have opened up and are vulnerable and are willing to share their stories. I feel obligated to make the best of that in the film that we make. That ultimately guides everything. But there’s also a benefit to that. With Times Up and MeToo, because two women came forward, more women came forward. When we bring this to audiences, they will consider what goes into the making of the films they watch and consume—who directed it, whether there was an intimacy coordinator, what the experience was like for the actors involved. The hope is that within the industry we can hold them to a certain accountability.

HHS: There’s an intimacy involved. We didn’t do more than two interviews per day, most days. We also had a look we were going for, and that took time and care. The thing about working with small crews is that it’s not always fast, so we had choices to make. We did the interviews with a modified Interrotron, which means there was a monitor on Kristy’s face and a monitor on the crew, which made it feel like an intimate conversation even though they were sitting twenty feet apart. Even though Kristy’s face wasn’t being recorded, she was on camera and it was a really emotionally engaging activity. Sometimes it wasn’t even the interviews that were draining; those are rewarding because you get to connect with people. But the prep time can be draining—watching a series of abusive behaviors or women being represented in a way that makes them uncomfortable. Kristy had many working nights where she would need to hide her screen from her young daughter because she didn’t want her to see what she was watching.

KGF: We were also really careful about how we presented this to audiences, so we were also really thinking about the impact of that as well. We didn’t want to re-traumatize people unduly. In terms of the images we shared, particularly with the ones where actresses were talking about unsettling or bad or violent experiences they had had on set, we didn’t want to re-exploit their likenesses for our audience and for them. We tried to be as careful as we could in that curation of clips. To show enough where people were able to understand what we were talking about while not contributing to a further exploitative process.